4 ms·
I wouldn’t even agree to getting a defined benefit pension these days - why wouldn’t you want to invest your own money instead of letting one company you happen
by chrisseaton 7y ago
I wouldn’t even agree to getting a defined benefit pension these days - why wouldn’t you want to invest your own money instead of letting one company you happened to work for control your pension?
I have a defined benefit pension from a previous employer and frankly I count it as zero in my financial planning since I have no idea if it’s actually coming or not.
- mikepurvis 7y agoAmericans love having the one company they happened to work for control their healthcare, though.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoIt still has value, assuming you're intending on working until you retire and the company has no signs of failling - why wouldn't you want a (nearly) guaranteed income for the rest of your life? That doesn't preclude you from investing your own extra cash into investments. I understand the dynamics have changed, but my boomer parents and in-laws are both enjoying retirement with the fruits of a defined benefit pension, and both are quite comfortable.
- lotsofpulp 7y ago30 years ago, if you said GE might be failing in 2019, you would have been considered crazy. There are no guarantees in life, even if the law says there are. The only reason your elders are enjoying the fruits of a defined benefit pension is because the costs of their pensions was hidden by an assumption of ever growing populations and economic growth. Additionally, why give control of your retirement funds to someone else when you can have control of your money? They're investing it in the same place as you would, and not getting any better returns.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoBecause when I retire they continue pumping money into the same funds - I can't do that, my contributions stop and I enter "withdraw" mode - the company doesn't. Yes, the plan can have problems, but I'm just saying why I think people still like it, and it does have definite advantages over your own savings.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> when I retire they continue pumping money into the same funds Lol you hope.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoIt's not without it's own faults, I get that.
- froindt 7y agoThere are so many ways it can go wrong - and when it does, the results can be disastrous. The article below mentions how poorly things can go, with private equity groups buying a company, things go poorly, it gets liquidated (pension gets dissolved), then the same private equity group buying it out of bankruptcy. Funny enough, with Marsh, the executive pension plan got a good payout relative to the thousands of store and warehouse employees. The pension isn't free to offer. I'd much rather they increase my base pay or give a more generous 401k match. https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/as-a-grocery-chain-is-dismantled-investors-recover-their-money-worker-pensions-are-short-millions/2018/12/28/ea22e398-0a0e-11e9-85b6-41c0fe0c5b8f_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/as-a-grocery...
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoPersonal savings can be equally disastrous - it's mismanagement of a pool or an individual. I get that individualism runs high, especially in this sector, which is running hot and people are enjoying being highly desirable, but pensions took the concern of managing retirement from the average worker for a generation. Would the average pensioned worker in 70's or 80's have had access to the education and resources required to ensure that they could save what they needed to to retire? I don't know.
- eternalny1 7y agoOn the flip side I know people who have completely squandered their 401k due to poor financial habits, and others who are getting a check, monthly, for life. Guess which one of those two is happier? Sure, you may say the first group was foolish, but we are talking your average American workers here not an investor-savvy class. Perhaps make it an option, if you want to gamble go for it, if you lose don't come crying for your retirement checks.
- ghaff 7y agoPaying out defined benefit plans aren't totally at the whim of the company. For example, there are protections through the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation and you could probably arrange for your own insurance as well. Having some savings as defined benefit does give you predictability. Even if you don't have a defined benefit plan through a company, it may make sense to convert some savings into an annuity of some sort.
- lotsofpulp 7y ago>For example, there are protections through the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation and you could probably arrange for your own insurance as well. The PBGC is just for show. They can't even guarantee the pensions of the multi employer defined pension plans that are about to fail, so there is a bill in congress to bail them out currently: https://burypensions.wordpress.com/2019/01/09/butch-lewis-act-re-introduced/ https://burypensions.wordpress.com/2019/01/09/butch-lewis-ac...
- cannonedhamster 7y agoCompanies just suckle up to the public teat when they make a bad business decision and it's always the employees that take it in the shorts. The executives get paid big bucks for making decisions but bear no responsibility for the results. It's all upside for them. That's a gamed system in need of being broken.
- walshemj 7y agoDon't take this the wrong way but you need to take some serious advice, DB pensions are far far better than a DC. Look at the transfer values of some DB pensions they can be worth multiple millions and no way would an individual be able to build up an equivalent amount in a DC scheame
- chrisseaton 7y ago> no way would an individual be able to build up an equivalent amount in a DC scheame Well if you put millions in you get millions out.
- nguoi 7y agoThere's no magic financial effect that makes the money going into a DB scheme worth more. The money has to come from somewhere and, in these cases, it's from companies that underestimated or ignored what the future costs would be.
- walshemj 7y agoYou do understand that DB is a collective scheme and DC its not just you. Your DB pension is funded by those that came before you and those coming after.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- nguoi 7y agoI'd love to hear how someone would intonate a statement beginning with 'you do understand' if they said it to me in meatspace.
- walshemj 7y agoSorry I should have phrased that better for those whose first language isn't English. Its phrasing in that sense would be similar to "Dude your making a big mistake"