3 ms·
It's hard to tell from the article, how narrow or broad is this ruling? Does this have general implications for how federal agency rules interact with state la
by nerdponx 7y ago
It's hard to tell from the article, how narrow or broad is this ruling?
Does this have general implications for how federal agency rules interact with state laws, or does it really only apply to this case?
- larkeith 7y ago"As a matter of both basic agency law and federalism, the power to preempt the States’ laws must be conferred by Congress. It cannot be a mere byproduct of self-made agency policy." I am very much not a lawyer, but I don't see why that wouldn't apply to other agencies. OTOH, I'm unsure if that's really a precedent implying anything, any more than a court ruling that Emperor Norton had no legal authority would have been - it's simply reaffirming that arbitrary declarations have no inherent legal force.