4 ms·
The problem isn't with angering dictatorships, it's about angering a lot of ordinary Chinese mainlanders who have been convinced that the HK protesters are trai
by simonh 7y ago
The problem isn't with angering dictatorships, it's about angering a lot of ordinary Chinese mainlanders who have been convinced that the HK protesters are traitors.
This is a serious problem, because it's simply not possible to persuade them otherwise, because the channels to do so are censored by the Chinese government. It's a crazily scary issue. My family is half Chinese and my niece came over from China this summer. The only things she knew about the HK protests was that some violent anti-mainlander anarchists had protested against the use of the Chinese flag on some buildings. The vast majority of mainlanders have never even heard of the extradition law.
As a result mainland Chinese see any support for the HK protesters as being a direct attack against the identity, nationality and integrity of China and Chinese people. Foreigners being seen as interfering is seen as further proof that the HK protests are incited by foreigners and are an anti-Chinese plot so unless it's handled very carefully it can make the situation worse, not better.
It's tough, but I think the best approach, if you do want to express support for HK, is instead to focus on the Censorship of the issues by the Chinese government.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoIt's not a question of censorship. This is caused by the protesters themselves (at least some of them). I'm in the UK and the Chinese people I know only need to watch the reporting on the BBC to be convinced that a lot of protesters are anti-China and potentially propped up by foreign forces: Violence, attacks on government buildings, attacks on the Chinese flag, flying foreign flags, calling on the Brits and Americans to intervene, etc. The actions of these protesters have ensured that the Chinese government cannot do anything but standing firm. I don't know what Chinese TVs show to the public on the mainland, but if they show what the BBC shows then the people can only be outraged and absolutely against the protesters. The way these protesters behave has completely drowned any message regarding democracy, which the Chinese public might actually be receptive to, though indeed that would be censored by the media on the mainland. That's another reason not to hand the government the stick to beat them with.
- sagichmal 7y agoLol.
- simonh 7y ago>The actions of these protesters have ensured that the Chinese government cannot do anything but standing firm. Standing firm on what though? Since hardly any Chinese people even know about the extradition law, what does standing firm on that achieve? It has zero relevance to the issue from a mainlander perspective, so conceding on it would have zero negative publicity impact. In fact none of the actual issues are visible to mainlanders at all.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoThe protests are no longer about the extradition law. It has been fully withdrawn. The current violent (and often visibly anti-China) actions ensure that the mainland's public opinion fully supports the government in taking a tough and inflexible stance against the protesters as long as violence and disturbances continue. The protesters should take a page from Gandhi's book: You couldn't fault him. In HK the government does not even need to try to fault the protesters...
- missosoup 7y agoYou mean as long as PLA keeps planting undercover operatives amongst the protesters as agent provocateurs to incite the violence that's then used as an excuse for a 'harder' stance? Please, ask me for sources. I have probably over a hundred unspinnable photos and videos collected from r/HongKong by now. New ones keep coming every day. Here's an appetiser: https://i.redd.it/0o2411874tj31.jpg https://i.redd.it/0o2411874tj31.jpg
- mytailorisrich 7y agoRight, all those hundreds, if not more of people are all undercover operatives and without them the protests would have stopped long ago. It was them who stormed the LegCo... This is not serious.
- missosoup 7y ago> As a result mainland Chinese see any support for the HK protesters as being a direct attack against the identity, nationality and integrity of China and Chinese people. While that's true, this is not the driving force behind China's foreign influence in situations like this. There is a far more centralised top-down movement to enact CCP influence outside of China. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Front_Work_Department https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Front_Work_Department https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confucius_Institute https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confucius_Institute https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overseas_Chinese_Affairs_Office https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overseas_Chinese_Affairs_Offic...
- PavlovsCat 7y ago> It's tough, but I think the best approach, if you do want to express support for HK, is instead to focus on the Censorship of the issues by the Chinese government. So basically we can't talk about things to Westerners like we would, because Chinese citizens might overhear on the web and freak out? And not complying is us interfering? What if suggesting so would get you ostracized in democracies? If you had to pick one or the other? > unless it's handled very carefully it can make the situation worse, not better. The violence against the protesters has been constantly ramping up, for months. It's not like the other side fails to understand the demands, they simply will ignore and brutalize the people until they stop protesting. Do you think there will be new information that will change things? > After all, an end in terror is preferable to terror without end. -- Leaflet #2 of the White Rose There might be no clean and neat way out of this, but none of the people you are asking to provide one wanted or started any of this. That burden is not on them. They came across an aggressor and a victim, and it's not just a misunderstanding that can be cleared up without stepping on anyone's toes. You either step on the toes of victim or aggressor -- since you are already aware of the deed, being neutral isn't an option. Yeah, it's not fun, but it doesn't become more fun by avoiding what cannot be avoided. And downvoting within 1 minute without reply just proves how important this is, and how long we have allowed ourselves to slip and prefer distortion and silencing over intellectually honest argument, even about uncomfortable things.
- simonh 7y agoI haven't down voted you, and here's my reply. I'm just showing how this is perceived from a mainlander perspective, and why people that could be allies have been manipulated into a confrontational stance. I think the best way to fight this is to point out the way they have been manipulated. It's a matter of tactics. I'm making a suggestion, that's all. > And not complying is us interfering? That is how it is perceived by mainlanders, due to the way they have been manipulated. This is a trap set by the CCP. When your enemy lays a trap, saying "I'm completely entitled to go where that trap is, nobody's going to impinge on my rights of free passage" and then walking straight into the trap doesn't help anybody. I am not advocating stepping on the toes of the protesters, or mainland Chinese. I'm saying attack the real target - the Chinese Communist Party. They are the real opponent here. Call them out. Point out their role. Show how they are manipulating the narrative. That's my advice.
- hos234 7y agoSo where did these conversations go? Just curious if she is heading back more aware or more confused.
- simonh 7y agoMore aware. She's over here for a few years studying as a postgraduate.
- alkonaut 7y agoThe NBA has to leave the money on the table in china, OR they need to be the source of information that the chinese are missing (Such as in this case). The third option is to effectively apply the censorshop of the issues from the Chinese government, to people in the US.
- simonh 7y ago>OR they need to be the source of information that the chinese are missing... That's exactly what I am advocating, in a smart way that effectively counters the CCP narrative.