3 ms·
> A daily standup, if done well and short That's the rub, though. Despite best intentions, sometimes things just go off into the weeds. It happens more often
by kelnos 7y ago
> A daily standup, if done well and short
That's the rub, though. Despite best intentions, sometimes things just go off into the weeds. It happens more often than I'd like, and it's happened on every team I've ever been on, at every company I've ever worked at. Sure, you can say, "well you're doing it wrong", but that's not helpful. Process should support how the team works, not define how the team works.
> helps one to focus on what's important
If you need to refocus someone every day, you've made a bad hire.
> sets the tone for the day
That's my job. I know what I'm supposed to be working on, and set my own tone.
> and unites the team as a tribe
Ugh, gross. We're not a "tribe", "family", whatever.
We're a team of co-workers working on a variety of tasks, who are not children and can be trusted to communicate adequately with the rest of the team, and honor our commitments. If you have someone on the team for whom that's not the case, again: you made a bad hire. Don't punish the rest of the team because you have someone who can't do their job.
I get that some people get off track sometimes. It happens, even to the most senior of people. The solution to that is called management. Regular 1:1s, making sure your team keeps their tickets updated, and getting regular (individual, asynchronous, as-needed) status updates. If someone is having an off day, or an off week, that should be addressed individually, not by preemptively assuming the worst of everyone on the team and instituting a daily standup.
- ElFitz 7y ago> > and unites the team as a tribe > Ugh, gross. We're not a "tribe", "family", whatever. To each his or her own
- kelnos 7y agoTrue, I suppose. But I think you'd be hard pressed to find even a plurality of developers who'd embrace the whole "my team at work is my tribe" thing. Perhaps it's motivating for some, but I would guess that for the majority of developers it would be an active turn-off, or at the very least neutral and not helpful. And, at it's face, it's simply false. Companies (and the teams within) are factually not families, or tribes, or anything of the sort. They are a group of people working together for economic gain. They share very little resemblance to families or tribes in real life, and I can't see making that comparison as anything but a plea for loyalty... loyalty that will never be returned by the company when it's not convenient. If I were interviewing at a company and they tried to justify having a standup using this rationale, I would stop considering them, as would many (most?) developers I know.
- hamilyon2 7y agoThis is closely related to one's self-assessment and the question of being right and doing right thing. If one is right, stand up do not matter. If one is wrong, they help greatly. You say : why should I suffer for unprofessional and weak team member who is wrong? But you forget to note that the same person could be right sometimes and doing great things and be utterly wrong and solving wrong problems some other times. Edit: a also wanted to add, that input from peers and peer pressure is not to be underestimated. Management is be wrong as often as any of us.
- kelnos 7y ago> But you forget to note that the same person could be right sometimes and doing great things and be utterly wrong and solving wrong problems some other times. No, I don't forget that, and in fact specifically addressed people having an off day, week, whatever.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gherkinnn 7y ago> Despite best intentions, sometimes things just go off into the weeds. True. Happens in every meeting. In which case anyone present can (and in my view) should get the meeting back on track. “This is off topic”, “can you/we discuss this later”, “this has nothing to do with why we’re here for”. Having strict time limits, a clear intent, and of course people enforcing it does make it possible. >> and unites the team as a tribe > Ugh, gross. We're not a "tribe", "family", whatever. Agreed. This stuff makes me gag.
- kelnos 7y ago> In which case anyone present can (and in my view) should get the meeting back on track. I absolutely agree that people can and should do that, but in practice, I often find that people don't. And I personally get tired of it; isn't it reasonable to take a dim view of a meeting where literally every time we have it, I (as an IC, whose job this should not be) have to prod people to stay on track?