5 ms·
You talk about governments as if they were an alien sentient life form ("governments ... feel entitled"). They're not. They are groups of people who serve con
by lisper 7y ago
You talk about governments as if they were an alien sentient life form ("governments ... feel entitled"). They're not. They are groups of people who serve constituencies. You could tell the exact same story in reverse: the lack of surveillance technology made people feel entitled to anonymous financial transactions. The feelings of entitlement (if you want to call them that) follow the available technology. But ultimately these decisions are always trade-offs between one feeling of entitlement in one constituency and another feeling of entitlement in another. In this case, one side feels entitled to privacy, the other, to security (or the illusion of security, which some people find valuable even in the absence of actual security).
I point this out not because I disagree with your baseline position that privacy is valuable. I don't. I point this out because i believe that arguing for it on the basis that government feelings of entitlement are somehow less legitimate than the feeling of entitlement of non-governmental constituencies is not going to be an effective strategy because it's based on a false premise.
- darawk 7y ago> I point this out not because I disagree with your baseline position that privacy is valuable. I don't. I point this out because i believe that arguing for it on the basis that government feelings of entitlement are somehow less legitimate than the feeling of entitlement of non-governmental constituencies is not going to be an effective strategy because it's based on a false premise. I am not arguing that. I was explaining the process by which the feeling of entitlement arose. The argument for the legitimacy of privacy rights is one I assumed I didn't have to make at all in this venue. I suppose we could have that debate if you want, but I was not trying to make that case here. If we assume as an axiom that privacy is a right, the question then becomes: how do we structure our governments and public institutions to protect those rights? And one answer to that is to be more intentional about which invasions of privacy we allow than perhaps we have been in the past. With the foreknowledge that governments and institutions will come to depend on any access they are given.
- lisper 7y ago> If we assume as an axiom that privacy is a right But you can't assume that. For everyone who thinks that privacy is a right you can find someone else who thinks that safety and security is a right. Neither of these follows from the laws of physics. Which one ends up being a right (or which one ends up being the more "fundamental" right that ends up trumping the other) is a function of what we as a society decide. So you can't win this fight simply by standing up on a soap box and proclaiming that privacy is a right. You have to come up with an argument for why losing privacy is a greater evil than letting the bad guys get away.
- nybble41 7y ago> For everyone who thinks that privacy is a right you can find someone else who thinks that safety and security is a right. You can't strip away people's privacy without violating their safety and security in the process. These positions are not in conflict. And "society" doesn't get to decide what is or is not a right. Individual people decide that for themselves.
- darawk 7y agoPlease read the rest of my comment. I'll say it again: None of what I am saying is an argument for privacy. We can have that debate if you want, but this is not it.
- kortilla 7y agoSecurity from the things that the violations of privacy are meant to stop is already a right. Most governments hold that children have the right to not be molested. It’s the governments duty to uphold that right whether they can read communications or not. A right to security absolutely does not mean no right to privacy. That’s a false dichotomy.
- shakna 7y agoI've witnessed in the last couple of years several politicians arguing vehemently for something their constituency wants, such as safe access to encryption, and then they're taken aside and briefed on something by the intelligence service, and completely flip their views. The constituency hasn't changed their views. The politician was still elected on the same platform. But they no longer serve the constituency. I can well-understand the feeling that the government is a separate entity, and behaves differently.
- ENGNR 7y agoAnd most likely what they're told is hey, do you really want to spend political capital on this and risk going against us, or do you want to pursue things you can change enough to get reelected
- roenxi 7y agoIt is very hard to put a finger on exactly why though. Politicians discover that their pro-good-ideas stance puts them at odds with powerful forces. Consistently. But it seems unlikely that there is an actual conspiracy afoot. There is some powerful incentive structure at work. Take war for example. It seems that consistently peaceful candidates are voted in then they end up invading somewhere. It may be military lobbying; but even then it seems a little strange that absolutely no progress gets made on issues that seem to have a remarkable amount of support from what must be most voters. People voting for humanity or economic reasons would agree that endless overseas wars are a mistake - that catches most voters. Realistically it should even catch the imagination of the foreign policy people; power projection is one thing, but killing foreigners doesn't put America in a great place for the next generation. It would almost be more helpful for politicians to honestly state why they keep flipping their positions rather than sending another smooth-talking politician in to see if they flip. Surely there must be some equilibrium where less people die but all the insiders are happy.
- shakna 7y agoSome of the turnarounds are utterly baffling. I would understand to a certain extent if the national intelligence briefing informs the politician of a dozen programs that are reliant on the premise and have prevented x number of attacks and so on. But I've seen politicians flip completely after a single 20mins meeting. From fiercely against to fiercely for. For those cases, I've held my judgement, because I don't have a non-insane answer for why this happened, but everyone involved is presumably a somewhat-logical human being, and people don't let go of beliefs easily.
- mattigames 7y agoIs easy to see that the government is not in the hands of anything one may call constituency but in the pockets of the most wealthy, such thing is easy to see when you read how the wealthy pay less taxes than they have ever done historically and even less than the average american[0] despite being only a tiny amount of people in favor of such policies. [0] https://i.imgur.com/xhYCQh4.mp4 https://i.imgur.com/xhYCQh4.mp4 (from https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/10/06/opinion/income-tax-rate-wealthy.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/10/06/opinion/incom...)
- andy_ppp 7y ago“constituencies” is a great untruth isn’t it, they largely serve themselves and the people who give them money.
- lisper 7y ago> the people who give them money What do you think "constituency" means?
- SmellyGeekBoy 7y agoIn the UK at least it has a very specific definition relating to a population of voters living in a defined geographic area.
- alkonaut 7y agoIf politicians in democracies can survive without serving their constituencies, that means their constituencies are letting them get away with that. For example: the voters might have failed to vote for sensible campaign financing reform so that politicians serve financial interests more than voters. In the end these possibilities are always given by voters, and they can only be taken away by voters.
- DocTomoe 7y ago... which implies there is an option on the ballot that has a hypothetical, "good", surveillance-free candidate. There is not.
- wsy 7y agoThat is again something the constituency can easily change. It just needs one of the many anti-surveillance voters to be willing to run for office.
- leppr 7y agoVoters don't vote on particular decisions, or even on decision makers for particular issues, they vote on one decision maker for all issues. How likely is it that an anti-surveillance candidate also happens to satisfy more than 50% of voters on aspects other than surveillance? Since surveillance is low on the list of priorities of most people, it's a rational choice for them to ignore the candidates' stance on surveillance while choosing their preferred candidate. As such, the stance of republican leaders on low-interest, non identity-defining aspects like surveillance is mostly unaffected by democracy.
- personlurking 7y ago>You talk about governments as if they were an alien sentient life form ("governments ... feel entitled"). They're not. They are groups of people who serve constituencies. Lately, I've been thinking about what's happening in HK, and how the protesters were pulling down facial recognition towers. Without that, the social credit system is crippled (a bit). If enough people made it their business to take down a tower, here and there, with enough frequency, the govt would probably find a way around it but, still, that big, powerful government weakens when the right/wrong citizens get together. And even when the govt says no masks are allowed, there are ways around that, too [1] 1 - https://www.reddit.com/r/specializedtools/comments/ddu3eh/hong_kong_wearable_face_projector_to_avoid_face/ https://www.reddit.com/r/specializedtools/comments/ddu3eh/ho...
- ses1984 7y ago>They are groups of people who serve constituencies. They also exist to serve themselves. That is not their purpose but that is what ends up happening with most institutions.
- zzzcpan 7y agoAren't you missing power hierarchy in those entitlement examples? If one entitled to something but has no power, does it really matter? It only matters if power is involved and the entitlement can be enforced.