5 ms·
We've torn down more than a million SROs. SROs would be the closest thing to just giving people a room. They typically have shared bathroom facilities down the
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
We've torn down more than a million SROs. SROs would be the closest thing to just giving people a room. They typically have shared bathroom facilities down the hall, a shared kitchen and the ability and permission to use a microwave, hot plate or similar to cook within the room. They typically have their own sink. They may have a private bath of their own in some cases, but generally have no kitchen. If you add a kitchen, it's now a studio apartment.
I suspect the organizations promoting the concept of Missing Middle housing aren't for bringing back SROs. One site used to describe "residential above commercial" as fitting the definition of Missing Middle housing, but they seem to have changed it to "live-work." This excludes the idea of small units, like SROs, above a rental office or other commercial space in a downtown area.
Maybe they did that to intentionally exclude SROs or maybe they aren't aware the change has this impact. Regardless of the logic, it suggests they aren't including SROs in their agenda.
Reintroducing SROs and boarding houses would be one way to provide genuinely affordable spaces for small households, such as single individuals, childless couples and single parents. I think we could even improve on what typically gets provided in our remaining SROs which tend to be in old buildings.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_room_occupancy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_room_occupancy
- maxsilver 7y ago> I suspect the organizations promoting the concept of Missing Middle housing aren't for bringing back SROs. Because they're a bad idea, that had terrible consequences, and most reasonable people have vowed never to repeat that mistake. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tenement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tenement It's not like building real housing costs that much more. Trying to downgrade housing to make it cheaper is by scrimping 50sqft here, or a bathroom over there, is like the textbook definition of "penny wise, pound foolish". --- Housing is expensive because land is monopolized, hyper-overinvested, and carries zero risk because of government-guaranteed bailouts. Housing in cities is expensive for the same reasons, plus the inherently higher costs of higher density in construction. Housing is not expensive because an apartment is required to have running water, a functional toilet, and enough floorspace for a mattress. That's just simply not the issue.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThat argument boils down to "I'd rather let poor people be homeless than allow less than middle class housing to exist at all." I spent nearly six years homeless. I got off the street by moving into an SRO. An SRO with access to electricity, heat, bathroom facilities etc beats the hell out of living in a tent, peeing in the bushes and living in fear of being rounded up by the police for being too poor for my existence to be legal. I'm working on resolving my personal problems and raising my income. I still struggle to make ends meet every single month. I'm not a drug addict and I don't have a mental health diagnosis. I do have two special needs sons who still live with me and I'm medically handicapped. If you really want to outlaw poverty, you basically need to start applying the death sentence to anyone who has intractable personal problems, no matter the cause. Beat up by your husband and no place else to go but a shelter? Oh, death penalty for you. Gave birth to a child with an expensive genetic disorder? The baby needs to die so you can keep being a productive member of society. Etc. I don't think that works so well, personally. Our current system does a poor job of helping people find their way back to a middle class life once things go wrong somewhere and, so far, no one is quite yet proposing the death penalty for such problems. Which means people barred from having minimal housing become an increasing drag on the system because they have no immediate way out of their predicament. That's not intended as hyperbole: The average life expectancy in the homeless population is estimated between 42 and 52 years, compared to 78 years in the general population. https://www.nationalhomeless.org/factsheets/health.html https://www.nationalhomeless.org/factsheets/health.html Our housing policies are killing people, just more slowly and with more plausible deniability than putting a bullet through their brain. And some do get murdered simply for being homeless. Four homeless individuals were murdered in their sleep in New York recently and three years ago someone was setting tents on fire in San Diego. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-new-york-crime/man-accused-in-fatal-beatings-of-four-homeless-people-in-new-yorks-chinatown-idUSKCN1WK0CR https://www.reuters.com/article/us-new-york-crime/man-accuse... https://www.foxnews.com/us/san-diego-police-looking-for-person-of-interest-in-string-of-homeless-murders https://www.foxnews.com/us/san-diego-police-looking-for-pers...
- maxsilver 7y ago> That argument boils down to "I'd rather let poor people be homeless than allow less than middle class housing to exist at all." No, it really doesn't. My argument boils down to "poisoned/expired milk is never worth it, even if it would help reduce the price of milk". > I spent nearly six years homeless. I got off the street by moving into an SRO. I'm glad you found something that's better than nothing. I totally get how an SRO helped you out, and that you want to maintain that step for others. That's a good and admirable thing. But this is not an argument for SROs. It's an argument for more real apartments. If you had not managed to land an SRO, but had instead found a coleman tent, and it had helped you out, should we provide free camping tents to the homeless? That's not a solution, it's a band-aid. SROs are obviously much much nicer than this, but ultimately are just a much nicer band-aid. --- We don't need to create "shittier" housing to get homeless people off the street. We don't need to revert back to tenements. The solution to homelessness is housing -- real housing -- the kind that meets all relevant local regulations. We can do this just as easily as SROs, for nearly the same price, there's zero reason not to build real housing for everyone. Including those with low income. Including those with no income. --- If your complaint is that no one is doing this housing (or not doing it properly), then I agree with you 100%. I personally believe housing is a fundamental human right, and that the government should be compelled to provide free housing to all citizens, automatically, by right of law. It should be systematically impossible for any citizen to ever be "homeless". (In the same way that's systematically impossible for a child to be "uneducated", since a public K-12 education is guaranteed for free to all citizens. In the same way that it's systemically impossible for almost any citizen to be "emergency-less", anyone can call 911 almost anywhere in the US, and be automatically connected to local emergency services, even if their cell phone isn't paid up, even if their provider is roaming, even if they borrowed it from a friend, even if they have no income at all, and so on)