3 ms·
Too bad the Boring Company would rather build their own transit systems than bore the tunnels for existing subway systems.
by jcranmer 7y ago
Too bad the Boring Company would rather build their own transit systems than bore the tunnels for existing subway systems.
- shmerl 7y agoWhy can't they do both?
- jcranmer 7y agoThey absolutely can do both, but they don't seem to be willing to do so.
- CrazyStat 7y agoDo you have evidence to show that the problem is Boring Company's unwillingness rather than hesitance by cities (perhaps under pressure from Boring Company's more established competitors) to bring in a relatively inexperienced partner for a major project like a new subway line?
- jcranmer 7y agoEverything they have publicly bid for has been about deploying their Loop transit system. They have not bid on any contracts or subcontracts for tunneling operations, so far as I can find, and their FAQ page spends more time discussing the Loop system than it does their tunneling technology.
- mncharity 7y agoThe Boring Company is a startup exploring a transformative sweet spot around very-inexpensive small simple autonomous-EV single-lane road tunnels, when constructed very rapidly at extremely large scale. If BC were to attempt a conventionally sized and outfitted subway tunnel, bid against established contractors, for one of the very few contracts available, presumably with a machine in direct competition with established TBM manufacturers... well, that would be quite a pivot.
- rohit2412 7y agoThat's pretty bullshit if you consider their USP is cheap tunneling. Then they should be just building cheap tunneling then trying to build custom public transit that allow only for electric cars with compatible self driving systems.
- mncharity 7y ago> Then they should be just building cheap tunneling then trying to build custom public transit Cheap depends on context. Here, on R&D, creating excellent machines, mass produced, and reused with high duty cycle, embedded in a big high-productivity surrounding process, all amortized and enabled by scale. And also on tunnel characteristics, especially small diameter (many costs scale roughly with face area). These are not well matched to existing markets. The sweet spot really is in system design, not merely in fancy small TBM design. The scale permits the cost that permits the scale. > custom public transit that allow only for electric cars with compatible self driving systems Access could indeed be an interesting issue at some point. But at present, company focus is on dedicated mass transit shuttle bus/vans. More analogous to rail transit, than to highways.
- delfinom 7y agoIt's not transformative. It does absolutely nothing to fix traffic/congestion. Because the real limitation is above ground where streets where people are being dropped off/parking/living/etc which have limited capacity and cascade into backups from local streets and onto highways. This just means there'll be back ups underground as well. Unless people are going to start living underground. Then you start to remove the above ground choke points ;)