3 ms·
> It seems fairly obvious that any new automated technology removes more jobs than it creates The clearest real world check for this theory should be the unemp
by BurningFrog 7y ago
> It seems fairly obvious that any new automated technology removes more jobs than it creates
The clearest real world check for this theory should be the unemployment rate.
If you're right, it should be steadily rising as more and more jobs are automated away.
- petra 7y agoIt's a bit too early. Last year only around ~400K new robots we're bought. This won't stay that way.
- BurningFrog 7y agoI have a different perspective. Since the industrial revolution ~250 years ago, human workers have constantly been replaced by machines. All this time people have been sure it would result in unemployment, and all this time they've been wrong. A worker today is about 30x as productive as one 250 years ago, because of this technological development. Now, of course, it could be different this time. The past doesn't dictate the future etc. But at a minimum I'd want to hear why from someone who understands the history.
- petra 7y agoOne historian that see AI as different is Yuval Noah harari. He has interesting books.
- BurningFrog 7y agoI'm reading Sapien right now.
- chillacy 7y agoThe unemployment rate doesn't include those who have given up, it's useful to look at the labor force participation rate. In particular for men ages 25-54 which are considered "prime aged": https://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2018/beyond-bls/mens-declining-labor-force-participation.htm https://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2018/beyond-bls/mens-declining-... Edit: here's a 2016 article showing an instance of unemployment rate going down (which looks good) because labor force participation rate dropped (which is not good): https://northcooknews.com/stories/511017085-illinois-workers-drop-out-of-labor-force-as-manufacturing-jobs-are-lost https://northcooknews.com/stories/511017085-illinois-workers... > While the unemployment rate dropped to 5.5 percent, it is still higher than the national average of 4.9 percent. In addition, the decrease is mainly due to unemployed workers dropping out of the labor force. The number of people on and off state unemployment who are looking for work determines the unemployment rate. When workers stop looking, they are no longer counted, which leads to an apparent decline in unemployment.