4 ms·
I was ready to be on Monica's side until I found and read the leaked Teacher's Lounge transcript. I'm now significantly more conflicted. In the chat, Monica wa
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
I was ready to be on Monica's side until I found and read the leaked Teacher's Lounge transcript. I'm now significantly more conflicted.
In the chat, Monica was asked many times, by many other moderators, to please use "singular they" for people who she actively knew preferred that pronoun. Monica flat out refused, saying it was confusing and grammatically incorrect. She said she'd be happy to use literally any other word, including "new" pronouns like "Xe". She also suggested that she could avoid using pronouns altogether, either just for people who preferred singular they, or universally for everyone. (Other moderators said this last option likely would have been fine had Monica not made known her reason for doing so.)
Now, on a purely personal level, I also find singular they to be super confusing in conversation, at least when the subject is unambiguous. But the extent to which Monica refused to budge, even after being told that she was making colleagues uncomfortable, struck me as behavior that would need to be disciplined in any formal workplace.
- blub 7y agoThere's no formal workplace where anyone would be disciplined because they don't want to use "they". This is simply not a concern in the real world, it's another storm in the internet outrage tea cup.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoWell, speaking personally, if I acted the way she did at my workplace, I expect I'd get a talking to.
- einpoklum 7y agoPlus - Monica doesn't even f'ing _work_ for them! She's a volunteer moderator, through elections. Well, she had been anyway.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoVolunteer positions are still positions with responsibilities. If you're doing more harm than good, any good organization will ask you to leave.
- einpoklum 7y agoIt's a position to which you're elected by users, not posted by the company which owns the website.
- danpalmer 7y ago> But the extent to which Monica refused to budge, even after being told that she was making colleagues uncomfortable, struck me as behavior that would need to be disciplined in any formal workplace. Whether you agree or disagree with the author's position, whether you agree or disagree with the Stack Exchange policies, a reasonable person acting in good faith would change their behaviour when told they are making others feel uncomfortable (unless perhaps they thought the change would make others more uncomfortable which doesn't appear to be the case here). This is pretty much the definition of good faith.
- blub 7y ago"a reasonable person acting in good faith would change their behaviour when told they are making others feel uncomfortable" Yes, in yesterday's world this would be sensible. Nowadays being uncomfortable is being weaponized to bully others into submission and this should be fought against. Being uncomfortable is part of the human existence and anyone should be able to feel uncomfortable and continue to function and continue to work with whoever is making them uncomfortable, unless that person is being downright offensive. Using "they" doesn't qualify, it's not even playing this game.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoI agree with you insofar as, this isn't about the policy itself so much as Monica's reaction to being told she was making others uncomfortable. However, I truly do believe from reading the chat that Monica had no ill intentions. She has strong feelings about the english language, and takes pride in upholding her own personal standards of quality in her writing. Furthermore, the entire conversation was overly heated. And much of the blame that can be placed on StackExchange—they dropped an ambiguous announcement into the chat without any context, and left everyone to discuss and interpret it amongst themselves instead of staying to answer questions.
- danpalmer 7y agoFair, I haven't read the original discussion and was more making a general point about the fact that feeling uncomfortable is the main concern here, not the specifics of the discussion, and it sounds like that's Stack Exchange's opinion as well.
- caconym_ 7y ago> Other moderators said this last option likely would have been fine had Monica not made known her reason for doing so. That reason being that it's "confusing and grammatically incorrect"? What does that have to do with the distinction between "people who preferred singular they" and "everyone"? > even after being told that she was making colleagues uncomfortable Where is the evidence that she was legitimately making colleagues "uncomfortable"? If I claim to be "uncomfortable" at work because my colleagues do X or don't do Y in their interactions with me, should that be taken at face value? Is my claim enough to have them removed if they don't correct their "problematic" behavior?