4 ms·
>>stop moving blame from yourself to others. I don't drive though. This article argues for preventing deaths, not litigating them. What's the use of assigning
by blue_devil 7y ago
>>stop moving blame from yourself to others.
I don't drive though.
This article argues for preventing deaths, not litigating them. What's the use of assigning blame after the fact?
You cannot force people to be more perfect than they are (or want to be). You can "nudge" the right outcome by shaping the environment.
If you google "chicanes in London", you'll see how people's behaviour can be shaped, regardless of their personality. _That_ is what you want, to ensure people's safety.
- maxaf 7y agoIf people can be nudged by street design or transparent B-pillars, they can also be nudged by heavy penalties that are commensurate with the deed.
- piptastic 7y agoWhich is why there are no murders in states with a death penalty.
- greggman2 7y agoIt seems like you're effectively saying MADD didn't work. Drunk driving never became less than it was in the late 1970s https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mothers_Against_Drunk_Driving https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mothers_Against_Drunk_Driving The claim they lowered drunk driving deaths by 1/2. I have no easy way to verify that but if true it certainly suggests people's behavior can be changed
- chongli 7y agoI don't know about your area, but where I live the police set up checkpoints along common routes home from popular bars/restaurants to catch drunk drivers. Drunk drivers get caught extremely often and many of them lose their licence for long periods of time. This does not discourage drunk driving as much as you would think. It does remove a lot of the drunk drivers from the road by force, however.
- beerandt 7y agoMADD only worked in the sense that it made some mothers feel somewhat absolved of whatever guilt they felt for losing a child. Their statistical claims are quite ridiculous, though. Edit: Claiming credit moreso than flawed statistics, although both are highly questionable.
- scottlocklin 7y agoEnforcement works in societies which actually enforce their laws. Try finding weed in Singapore for example.
- edoceo 7y agoDo NOT try to get weed there.
- eth0up 7y agoYou probably could, however, find hordes of repressed maniacs and neurotics discouraged enough by it to hesitate a bit. At least if you could keep them out of motor vehicles ;)
- chongli 7y agoThis would only work if the penalties were enforced a very large percentage of the time someone did something unsafe, regardless of the outcome. Humans respond to light punishments consistently applied far better than harsh punishments rarely applied. It would be far more effective if you applied a $5 fine every time a person looked at their phone screen while driving than if you instituted the death penalty which applied only when a distracted driver kills a pedestrian.