3 ms·
Answers to the title question: * Transition away from physical controls to touchscreen controls in new cars * American's love affair with the automatic transm
by colechristensen 7y ago
Answers to the title question:
* Transition away from physical controls to touchscreen controls in new cars
* American's love affair with the automatic transmission
* Car-unfriendly "progressive" movements and the return of population towards city centers
It seems like people have very little actual interest in making things better but only interest in blaming something they have a built-in bias against or promoting a technology they find interesting.
The article completely failed to mention manual transmissions in America and the rest of the world while wondering loudly why it is so different here and the prevalence of touch-screens not just on phones in cars. Automatics are much more popular in the US and having a manual transmission forces you to pay much more attention to driving and simply occupies both hands more often especially inside cities.
One thing emphasized way too little is the responsibility of the pedestrian for not getting hit – the feeling of entitlement to right of way leading to people just not paying attention to cars or expecting behavior instead of watching for it.
I grew up around farm machinery often with little visibility and it teaches you to pay attention to what is going on around you a lot more. Not just in a way of being ready to react because there are circumstances where reacting is impossible, but in knowing what movements a machine is capable of and what the operator intends to do as well as if the operator knows you are there at all.
This is one of the primary reasons I think robot cars will go absolutely nowhere. It is impossible to come up with a theory of mind for a robotic car. As a pedestrian all you usually need to know the intentions of a driver (or vice versa) are an instant of eye contact. We are evolved to use tiny signals to decide intent and many people are barely aware of this. That kind of information just can't be reliably exchanged with a machine.
And people just aren't expecting the kinds of things which will happen when people start to believe robots with super fast reaction times will do anything not to hit pedestrians. Pedestrians will start running into the street without a care (or as a cheap thrill)
The article missed a lot and spent too much time on the wrong topics.
- GordonS 7y ago> American's love affair with the automatic transmission I don't agree with your point here. I switched to auto boxes around 10 years ago, and (if anything) they free me up a bit to be more aware of my surroundings, because I don't have to spend any of my attention on using a clutch and gear stick. Fully agree about touchscreen controls though - if controls are physical and tactile, I can easily use them without diverting my eyes from the road.
- Johnny555 7y ago"American's love affair with the automatic transmission" I don't buy this as a contributing factor at all -- when you drive a manual transmission car regularly, the shifting becomes second nature and you don't need to actively think about it -- I can zone out in my manual transmission car just as much as when I drive the no-transmission EV. In Japan, cars are almost all entirely automatic transmission cars, but their accident rate is less than 30% compared to the USA. This is one of the primary reasons I think robot cars will go absolutely nowhere. It is impossible to come up with a theory of mind for a robotic car. It's not impossible for the autonomous car to tell you that it sees you -- it could aim a "I see you" light at you, or maybe pop up an indicator on your smart watch or Google Glass to say that it sees you. It's not like catching a driver's eye is 100% reliable -- I've had drivers look right at me while they pull out in front of my bike at an intersection.