5 ms·
A dozen (!) pages listing the contributors, then an abstract which ends with the paragraph quoted below which essentially says it's more powerful and wth vague
by mellosouls 7y ago
A dozen (!) pages listing the contributors, then an abstract which ends with the paragraph quoted below which essentially says it's more powerful and wth vague aims.
I hope the intended audience aren't political and financial decision makers who are otherwise laymen on the subject.
Presumably this is aimed at fellow scientists? What's the goal of the document? What is the specific Higgs-equivalent target of the proposed collider? I didn't read further tbh, I wasn't encouraged by the first few pages, but then I'm not a physicist so perhaps that isn't intended.
From the abstract:
the FCC-hh design aims at significantly
extending the energy frontier to 100 TeV. Its unprecedented centre-
of-mass collision energy will make the FCC-hh a unique instrument
to explore physics beyond the Standard Model, offering great direct
sensitivity to new physics and discoveries.
- whatshisface 7y agoCERN culture dictates that everyone involved with the team should be listed as contributors. This is due to the fact that experimental result papers, written up by small teams who analyze data, are only made possible by the work of many other scientists who do not themselves produce papers. The contributor list probably includes everyone that would normally be listed as part of any paper published by the group.
- mellosouls 7y agoThanks - I understand the idea, but I think it would be better suited to an appendix.
- beojan 7y agoFollowed by the table of contents and the actual CDR. You can't skip the details then ask "Where're the details?"
- mellosouls 7y agoI didn't ask for the details. There were too many details before a point revealed itself. I asked for the specific overarching, clearly specified. targeted discovery goal of the whole thing. Feel free to answer that - it appears to be missing from the abstract. Why would I continue beyond the abstract if it is not clear what the specific goal of the project is and I've already gone through a dozen pages to get there?
- sdwa 7y agoThat's not really the point of a CDR, it's saying "if we were to build a 100TeV machine, this is, broadly speaking, how we would do it". Particle physicists may (or may not) determine it worthwhile, that's another question altogether.
- mellosouls 7y agoThank you. That makes sense (and why I asked about the intended audience and purpose of the document); however as they put the blue sky goals in the abstract, I would have expected something more specific as well.
- siscia 7y agoSorry, but I am afraid you are ill informed on the ammount of complexity that this document cover. Please note that never ever in the history of mankind a project so ambitious has even be thought. Already the amount of complexity in LHC is considered far greater than the complexity of the Apollo mission. FCC is a different order of magnitude than LHC already. Then if you just skim the report you will notice how wide are the topic covered. Leaving aside the physics, the document talk about the magnets, how to detect quenches, how to discharge magnets that hold 37MJ of energy, how to monitor the beam of particle, how to dump the beam, how to inject the beam into FCC, how to accelerate the beam,how to keep 100km of magnets at 1.9k when particles at 100TeV are running inside and doing it not for a bit, but continuosly for months and months. And then other points more pragmatic, where to get the electric energy to run the whole machine? And this just skimming the document and looking at pictures. Honestly, how many would you expect to write such a document?
- mellosouls 7y agoI think you've completely missed my point and have not answered a single of my questions. In particular, I'd like you to not "leave aside the physics" - my understanding is that's quite important here - and specify what part of theory this will confirm or reveal. I may well be "ill-informed", I'm happy for you to clear that up with an example along Higgs-discovery lines - the abstract and first dozen pages were unable to. You reference the Apollo mission as a relatively minor affair in comparison, so that could serve as an example. What is the "putting a human being on the moon" thing we are doing here? The abstract as it stands is more like "we're gonna shoot some multi billion dollar rockets into space and see what happens".
- Someone 7y agoI wonder whether it is worth spending as much as this would cost, but I don’t expect that to be answered in a “Conceptual Design Report. Design time is not where you justify why you’re building what you’re building; you only describe how you’re planning to do it. Presumably (I haven’t looked hard for them) there are earlier report(s) that argue why we would want to look at 100 TeV. Edit: https://fcc-cdr.web.cern.ch/ https://fcc-cdr.web.cern.ch/ has some more high-level info, such as ‘FCC Physics Opportunities’ (https://fcc-cdr.web.cern.ch/#FCCPO https://fcc-cdr.web.cern.ch/#FCCPO), which refers the “European Strategy for Particle Physics” (https://europeanstrategyupdate.web.cern.ch/ https://europeanstrategyupdate.web.cern.ch/) which, presumably answers the ‘why’