3 ms·
Your suggestion would be a horrific fit for a mainstream car in the model 3’s category. Fuel economy, emissions, and long term reliability are why they don’t p
by Retric 7y ago
Your suggestion would be a horrific fit for a mainstream car in the model 3’s category. Fuel economy, emissions, and long term reliability are why they don’t put an engine like that in a Honda Accord.
In terms of real world preference, EV’s and plug in hybrids low speed handling characteristics are vastly more useful than top speed. So the 200hp Honda Engine is arguably undersized even in a lighter car.
- SECProto 7y agoYup. I drive a lot and don't care much about performance as long as I can get up to highway speed on the on-ramp. Fuel economy, maintenance, longevity all matter a great deal.
- Judgmentality 7y agoA Tesla Model 3 usually sells for something like $50,000, I'd guess - it's not competing with a Honda Accord. This article is a year old so it's outdated, but it suggests an average sale price of $60,000 for the Model 3. This clearly puts it in the luxury/performance price bracket. https://cleantechnica.com/2018/08/23/tesla-model-3-average-selling-price-asp-59300-surveys-find/ https://cleantechnica.com/2018/08/23/tesla-model-3-average-s... Apart from that, the EA888 engine I mentioned is used in the VW Golf, the 7th best selling car in the world. https://www.best-selling-cars.com/global/2018-full-year-international-global-top-selling-car-models/ https://www.best-selling-cars.com/global/2018-full-year-inte... The engine is considered highly fuel efficient, rated well above 30mpg for most variants and many people report >40mpg in real world usage (obviously this data will be biased towards higher numbers). The emissions, however, are supposedly great but I don't trust VW at all on this front so I'll just assume they're doing something shady. They are being legally sold in California though, which is really the highest emissions bar there is, so I'm not sure what you'd expect from them (again, assuming they aren't doing shady shit). And unusually for VW, this is considered a reliable engine. It's been around and iterated upon for much longer than any Tesla. There is no apples-to-apples comparison between electric and gasoline vehicles, but claiming one of the most highly awarded engines in recent history is lacking in performance is like claiming Teslas are worthless in cold climates - it's more rumor than fact.
- Retric 7y agoI personally know people considering a mid tier Honda Accord vs the base model 3. The numbers they have run provide similar lifetime costs, though clearly many early adopters are less price conscious. Historically, Tesla was not going to make a base model when their was more profit from manufacturing a more expensive car. Back to that IC engine “With a mild tune” is an issue. You can get reasonable performance on a tiny hatchback with the stock 149 bhp EA888 but that’s not going to cut it on a midsized sedan. Want more performance from the same basic hardware and you will make some real sacrifices, weight, fuel economy, engine life, etc one or more things need to give. Pretending otherwise is to suggest vast numbers of automotive designers are idiots.
- Judgmentality 7y agoI feel like you just ignore all the numbers I write and invent new ones. A stock Golf R with an EA888 engine makes 292 hp and 280 lb-ft of torque - significantly more than any Accord you can buy new. A Golf R with a mild tune (just software) will generate closer to 350 hp, and moderate-serious tunes start around 400 hp. They also use this engine in their Passat, which is a mid-size sedan which competes directly with the Accord and weighs about the same. https://www.goapr.com/products/ecu_upgrade_20tsi_gen3_mqb_r.html https://www.goapr.com/products/ecu_upgrade_20tsi_gen3_mqb_r.... I'm sorry, but at this point I'm just going to say you have no idea what you're talking about when it comes to IC engines and exit this thread.
- Retric 7y agoYou need to be making an apples or apples comparison for different numbers to be meaningful. The base golf gets 25 city / 34 highway a Golf R gets 22 city / 29 highway. With a mid tune that golf R gets even worse mileage. These numbers drop further when you talk about a larger car with more wind resistance or weight. https://www.fueleconomy.gov/feg/PowerSearch.do?action=noform&path=1&year1=2018&year2=2018&make=Volkswagen&baseModel=Golf%2FGTI&srchtyp=ymm https://www.fueleconomy.gov/feg/PowerSearch.do?action=noform... Meanwhile the larger Honda Accord is getting 30 city, and 38 highway. https://www.fueleconomy.gov/feg/PowerSearch.do?action=noform&path=7&year=2019&make=Honda&model=Accord&srchtyp=ymm https://www.fueleconomy.gov/feg/PowerSearch.do?action=noform... Taking a 25+% cut to fuel economy to use a lighter engine is a really bad tradeoff for most people. Especially when the point of this discussion was talking about fuel density comparisons. On top of this IC’s also need a much larger and more complex transmission among other things which should be included in the weight comparison.