3 ms·
It's not a benefit, it's a joke. Nuclear spacecraft were never valuable enough for NASA to spend much money on; why should they justify the enormous cost pena
by pfdietz 7y ago
It's not a benefit, it's a joke. Nuclear spacecraft were never valuable enough for NASA to spend much money on; why should they justify the enormous cost penalty of new nuclear power plants?
(BTW, the reactors in power plants would be useless for spacecraft.)
- rayiner 7y agoThere are lots of uses for nuclear technology in space other than propulsion. Nuclear has huge power to weight advantages, critical for space. Nuclear would also be vastly cheaper if we deregulated the industry and enabled mass production of components, as with nuclear and solar. (As it is, China will ship us subsidized solar while developing thorium technology itself, enabling it to become the dominant technological superpower.)
- pfdietz 7y agoThe point is these are niche applications that cannot carry the weight of justifying civilian nuclear power.
- rayiner 7y agoThese are not “niche applications.” Increased energy production to enable better weapons, better transportation, and increased production is what has historically enabled leaps in civilization. The first country to perfect nuclear fusion is going to have a huge advantage over everyone else. Conservation and wind power aren’t going to take you in that direction.
- pfdietz 7y agoWait, you were talking about space, not "energy production" in general. The space applications are niche, because space itself is niche. Your claims there with respect to terrestrial energy production are not justifications for nuclear. Wind and solar are much cheaper than nuclear, and rapidly getting even cheaper.
- chipsa 7y agoSpace is niche right now, and will always be niche until we get off this rock and have space colonies.
- pfdietz 7y ago> Nuclear has huge power to weight advantages, critical for space. The most powerful space nuclear reactor ever launched, the Soviet Topaz-I, had a specific power of 16 KW(e)/kg. The PV system on the NASA Juno spacecraft, at 1 AU, had a specific power of 50 kW(e)/kg. Perhaps you are talking about aspirational PowerPoint engineering nuclear concepts (and ignoring similarly advanced PV concepts), or maybe systems operating in the outer solar system. But otherwise, no, solar has the weight advantage over nuclear, not the other way around.
- p_l 7y agoOh, they were. NASA was working very hard on nuclear propulsion, and even managed to get support from Congress in the budget, something they never had for Shuttle. Took direct presidential order to dismantle the project and essentially bury nuclear space propulsion.
- pfdietz 7y agoThe point I am making is that when push comes to shove, NASA doesn't rate nuclear propulsion work highly. It's not what's keeping us out of space. The value to the nation of nuclear rockets is reflected in what $$ are budgeted to them.
- p_l 7y agoThe way things are budgeted in USA doesn't reflect much on value the nation puts on anything. That said, US Congress did fund it, on a rather non-pork-barrel project, even. It just happened to have enmity pf Nixon's administration, to the point that they arranged for NASA to scrap Space Nuclear Propulsion Office and laid off everyone involved, despite 100m budget and the project being well on track.