2 ms·
It’s political. The American left has taken an anti-science, moralistic stance on climate change.[1] Fixing climate change through technology, without changing
by rayiner 7y ago
It’s political. The American left has taken an anti-science, moralistic stance on climate change.[1] Fixing climate change through technology, without changing the economy or politics, doesn’t serve desired ends. While most people here are scientifically minded, they’re also generally left leaning, and the opposition to nuclear power is part of that platform.
[1] That’s not to suggest the right has embraced science by denying climate change is happening. As far as I can tell, the right’s solution to climate change is “god won’t let anything bad happen.” The left’s isn’t any better or more realistic. I’m at a Costco in the Maryland exurbs. A hugely diverse crowd (black, Hispanic, Asian, white) is doing their weekend shopping. Families with 2+ children in tow. No joke, some just shouted out “living the suburban dream” while we were eating froyo. Then they’re going to get into their SUVs and go home to their, on average, 2,000+ square foot house.
The idea that we’re going to solve climate change by having all these people move to 500 square foot apartments in the city, going only where the government decides to build public transit, and limiting themselves to one kid, is utter fantasy. In fact the opposite will happen. Chinese, Indians, Bangladeshis, Africans... they’ll get Costco and SUVs. Hoping otherwise is just as unrealistic as thinking God will fix things.
- joshuamorton 7y agoI'm fairly pro nuclear. There was a time when nuclear was probably the best solution to stop climate change. But that time was 5, maybe 10, years back. Since then, solar and wind have caught up significantly in terms of efficiency. And given the dearth of new nuclear in the us, safely bringing up a reactor, if we started building tomorrow (ignoring the political challenges of where), would take the better part of a decade to be operational. Solar and wind brings faster returns. Really we just need to stop subsidizing coal and similar.
- rayiner 7y agoIt’s not just a matter of efficiency. Investment in nuclear has major collateral effects that investment into wind and solar does not have. You won’t have wind powered spaceships. You can’t use wind power to for weapons or aircraft carriers. Nuclear fusion is going to be the bedrock of the next generation of world superpowers. Wind and solar are technological dead ends.
- pfdietz 7y agoSpaceships? That's the supposed payoff for an energy source that is 4x the levelized cost of the competition? I tell you what: if someone wants nuclear spacecraft, let THEM pay for it.
- rayiner 7y agoIf we’re going to subsidize a technology we should think about the whole range of benefits.
- pfdietz 7y agoIt's not a benefit, it's a joke. Nuclear spacecraft were never valuable enough for NASA to spend much money on; why should they justify the enormous cost penalty of new nuclear power plants? (BTW, the reactors in power plants would be useless for spacecraft.)
- rayiner 7y agoThere are lots of uses for nuclear technology in space other than propulsion. Nuclear has huge power to weight advantages, critical for space. Nuclear would also be vastly cheaper if we deregulated the industry and enabled mass production of components, as with nuclear and solar. (As it is, China will ship us subsidized solar while developing thorium technology itself, enabling it to become the dominant technological superpower.)
- pfdietz 7y agoThe point is these are niche applications that cannot carry the weight of justifying civilian nuclear power.
- rayiner 7y agoThese are not “niche applications.” Increased energy production to enable better weapons, better transportation, and increased production is what has historically enabled leaps in civilization. The first country to perfect nuclear fusion is going to have a huge advantage over everyone else. Conservation and wind power aren’t going to take you in that direction.