4 ms·
While I sympathise with your sentiment, viable is enough. We aren't exactly sd spoilt for choice
by ClumsyPilot 7y ago
While I sympathise with your sentiment, viable is enough. We aren't exactly sd spoilt for choice
- rbanffy 7y agoThere are many other things we could do that are as viable, if not more - we barely started using wind or solar, and while wind and solar may be poor replacements for coal, hydro or nuclear, it's excellent for cars and trucks and they are a significant portion of our energy matrix. We will eventually need to increase the fission base, if fusion continues to be 10 years away for much longer, but that's something that can wait until we have better designs than the current generations. What nuclear really excels at is at replacing coal. It's pretty much a plug-in replacement: nuclear generation can be built pretty much wherever coal can and, from the grid's perspective, it looks a lot like coal. This, along with industry subsidies (both direct and as military expenditure) has always shifted economics towards it.
- pfdietz 7y agoWhy will we eventually need to increase the fission base? I see no good justification for that. > What nuclear really excels at is at replacing coal Coal is being displaced, but not by nuclear. Nuclear is actually rather bad at displacing coal. People were building coal fired power plants for decades when they could have been building nuclear plants, because nuclear failed at being attractive enough to replace coal.
- rbanffy 7y agoNuclear is dense and constant, far more dense than wind or solar. BTW, burning coal for energy should be considered a crime against humanity. It should be replaced by anything, regardless of energy output ;-)
- pfdietz 7y ago"Density" only matters insofar as it affects cost. And wind and PV come out much cheaper than nuclear, so density is clearly not very important. One could have figured this out by looking at the cost of land vs. the cost of wind/solar equipment put on that land. As for constancy... this is actually a negative for nuclear, since the business case for nuclear assumes it can sell its output at a high average price, 24/7. And increasingly that market isn't there.
- rbanffy 7y agoDensity will eventually become relevant. What is the maximum human population of the Earth? How much energy would a planet-sized city need? How much space for cultivation or food manufacture? Agreed about the current market factors, but constant is easier to manage.
- pfdietz 7y agoIf density becomes relevant for solar, then nuclear is no solution. At that very high power usage, the raw thermal pollution from nuclear will limit it to below what solar can provide. Of course, this will be at an energy usage that is so incredibly high that it has no relevance to anything we do today. So it's a silly point of no relevance to current decisions.