5 ms·
This whole thing fails to account for the fact that on every subsequent round of funding, your percent ownership goes down. Even if the company is doing well,
by jedberg 7y ago
This whole thing fails to account for the fact that on every subsequent round of funding, your percent ownership goes down. Even if the company is doing well, at the next round of funding, you'll pretty much be reset to the original value if you're lucky. If you're very lucky your options might be worth more.
VCs have gotten too good at extracting value from a company. In this day and age, I consider startup options to be worth $0.
If I'm looking at a startup, it's because I am either super excited about their idea, or super excited about having a lot more responsibility/learning opportunities than at an established company.
Those are the factors I'm valuing in my head vs. the actual dollar opportunity cost.
- the_svd_doctor 7y agoCan you explain "on every subsequent round of funding, your percent ownership goes down" ? Maybe a naive question. But if you are given say 50% of a company, how can your percentage of ownership decrease if someone funds it ? What's the mechanism for this ?
- rohit2412 7y agoStock dilution I assume
- fsociety 7y agoBasically they create new stock to issue out, which increases the total number of stock in the company in turn diluting the percentage of stock you own
- cedricd 7y agoSay you have 50% of the company and your cofounder has the other 50%. That's all the stock, right? If you want to raise money you need to sell some stock. So the company creates new stock and sells that -- increasing the total number of shares. You don't get any of that new stock yourself, so your total ownership percentage goes down.
- patrickthebold 7y agoWhat you are saying is true, but at least in theory you don't lose any 'value', because the money raised makes the company worth more. It's like going from 50% of a $1m company to 25% of a $2m company. Of course in real life things are much more complicated. And, if I was a cynic, I'd say they are purposely complicated in an effort to screw people over.
- shiblukhan 7y agoThere are a number of additional factors not modeled here that affect real world decision making. First, most option grants revert ownership to the company if not exercised within 90 days of leaving the company. If the company is doing well, it only makes sense to leave if you can exercise. But the problem with exercising is that there can be enormous AMT tax liability if the company is doing well and the valuation has gone up substantially. For early employees, the taxes can easily be 10-20x the exercise cost or more. But since the stock is illiquid, there is no market for selling some of the stock to cover this liability. If you front the taxes with your own money (or worse, a loan) you are now in a position of enormous risk. If the company falters or collapses, your downside is huge and you can be hundreds of thousands of dollars in debt.
- harlanji 7y agoFurther, options come from a pool of stock that has last priority for cashing out. Preferred stock holders will get all value first, meaning an exit for less than the issued stock value will leave options holders empty handed. Sorry if I mixed up any important words, I’ve been out of the game for a couple of years.
- wolco 7y agoIn real life. The founders and angel shares do not delute and your percentage goes down each round. If your lucky they are worth the same.
- spullara 7y agoFounder and angel shares absolutely dilute with additional rounds of funding unless you have provisions that are very rare in term sheets and founder agreements.
- twic 7y agoDilution: https://startupxplore.com/en/blog/dilution-shares/ https://startupxplore.com/en/blog/dilution-shares/ The fundamental mechanism is that new investment is met by issuing new shares. If you hold options on a constant number of shares, and the number of shares into which ownership is divided goes up, then your fractional share of ownership goes down.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mandelbrotwurst 7y agoThe other responses in this thread are correct, but I suspect may have still left you confused. You are correct that 50% is always 50%, but employee stock options are typically given as a number of shares, not as a percentage of the total, which is what allows for dilution. At least, that's how I understand it.
- luckylion 7y agoAny number of shares at any given point is a percentage of the company, and any percentage is always a certain number of shares. You won't stay at that percentage though, unless the founders agree to protect you from dilution. In that case, they'd compensate you with some of their own shares whenever you dilute to keep your percentage the same. It's not common for employees though.
- loeg 7y agoThe point is that dilution works by creating new shares out of thin air -- the total number of shares increases. Meanwhile, the total percent remains 100%, for obvious reasons.
- luckylion 7y agoSure, but that doesn't change whether you're giving out a number of shares or a percentage, because both are the same, just expressed differently. There's no common theme where somebody says "here are 0.1% of the company" and implies anti-dilution. It's just easier to talk about percentages than shares, because it's easier to calculate if you know the total valuation. You'll dilute in both cases.
- draw_down 7y agoIf the business is doing well enough, they have the leverage raise on terms that are protective of employees’ equity. At least in the current environment.
- luckylion 7y ago> Even if the company is doing well, at the next round of funding, you'll pretty much be reset to the original value if you're lucky. Obviously depends on the situation and what valuation you got, but unless it's a down round, your percentage will be reduced, but that reduced amount will be worth more (on paper). Sure, you might no longer have 1% of a company valued $1m, you'll now have 0.5% of a company valued $5m.
- jedberg 7y agoExcept that it almost never actually goes that way. Instead what you get is .5% of a $5M company which has a $3M preference for the latest investor, leaving you with .5% of $2M, or exactly the same thing. Except more complicated than that.
- luckylion 7y agoThat would be uncommon in my experience. Investors won't get the difference between the current and the last valuation as a liquidation preference, they'll typically demand one as high as their investment. Understandably, they don't want to throw in a million, get 20% of the company only to have the company disband and receive 20% of the $1m back. The $5m won't come from a $3m investment, though. They'll take 20% for $1m, leading to a $5m valuation. And I don't know anyone that would give them a $3m liquidation preference in that deal. If your cash-on-paper (that is: shares vs total valuation) share doesn't grow in a round, that's a good time to think about getting out. If they were valued at $5m and are seeking investments valuing the company at $2m, run. Yes, investors aren't throwing money around like they maybe used to, but I don't believe there's reason to be overly pessimistic. If the company becomes successful, you'll make money if you've been on board early enough (that is: if you took on risk).
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tomp 7y agoWhy would investors go for that? In case of no investment, the company goes under, so you get 1% of $0. Therefore, you should be happy with pretty much any kind of dilution, new investors can easily force existing shareholders to get e.g. 0.1% of $5m.
- tempsy 7y agoGenerally you're going to raise at a higher valuation, so the fact that your percent ownership goes down at a higher share price isn't a bad thing. It's when you raise at the same valuation or lower valuation where it can be painful.