4 ms·
Well, I can think of at least one good reason for a medallion system: it helps limit the number of cars on the road. (Let's ignore Uber and Lyft—they are taxis
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
Well, I can think of at least one good reason for a medallion system: it helps limit the number of cars on the road. (Let's ignore Uber and Lyft—they are taxis and should need medallions, but we're not enforcing the law properly.)
Of course, it would help a great deal if the medallion system were combined with limits on private vehicles...
- briandear 7y agoMaybe people need medallions? If you don’t have a medallion then you have to return to the place from which you came. There would be fewer people on the roads and sidewalks. NYC sidewalks are too crowded and we should limit the number of people allowed to use them. The people-medallion system could be used in the Bay Area as well since housing is scarce. You could also require such a medallion to work and access public benefits. It seems like we do have such a system but we’re not enforcing the law properly.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoIt’s a terrible way to limit the number of cars. A variable toll would be a much better way of limiting the number of vehicles.
- ineedasername 7y agoI hate the idea of "congestion pricing" tolls. Bridges & tunnels into NYC run $15. $300/month for daily commuters. I'm sure that's manageable for some commuters, but poorer folks are disproportionately impacted and it significantly raised bus fair as well: About $260/month for most routes that are only 10-15 miles outside of NYC. I think better mass transit options are a better option to reduce congestion, and therefore the need for congestion pricing.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoMass transit is not an option in the next decade. And the solution to prices impacting poor people is to give poor people money, not to remove the mechanism by which resources get allocated (transparent pricing).
- admax88q 7y agoCongestion taxes/fees incentivize taking public transit options. I don't think anyone arguing for congestion tax is along arguing against mass transit, the two go hand in hand.
- ineedasername 7y agoI haven't seen either a decrease in congestion or an increase in mass transit infrastructure spending in NYC as a result of congestion pricing. And congestion pricing applies to busses as well, increasing mass transit cost. So commuting to NYC by car costs about $300 a month, but busses are still about $240 a month. Really not enough to strongly incentives mass transit. Maybe what it boils down to for me is that congestion pricing, in theory, may be a valid option. But in its implementation it accomplishes very little except increasing bloated budgets for organizations that focus too little on their actual mission.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoExactly, make the car cost $3,000 and you’ll start seeing some changes.
- ineedasername 7y agoThat's probably true, but then there needs to be a rapid coinciding ramp up of public transport like doubling or tripling the fleet of busses. Which could work! And it would have the added benefit of ever so incrementally reducing emissions from vehicles.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago> So commuting to NYC by car costs about $300 a month, but busses are still about $240 a month. Of course, that $300 leaves out the cost of the car, maintenance on the car, insurance, etc. The cost of the bus needs to account for all of that.
- TheCoelacanth 7y agoMass transit requires money to pay for it; congestion pricing brings in money. The two ideas aren't in opposition to each other; they are complementary.
- ineedasername 7y agoMass transit should pay for itself. A bond issue that is paid back out of the revenue generated. Money generated from congestion pricing though has (in NYC) simply been funneled to the increasing Port Authority operating budget with no impact on congestion as there are more cars than ever. If it was genuinely used for capital improvement to mass transit I wouldn't mind as much.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoCongestion pricing is great and we should do that to. However, taxis generally can enter the city once and drive around all day.
- ineedasername 7y ago>limits the number of cars on the road" Would it though? If the supply of taxis was more ubiquitous is would drive down relative demand and therefore prices, as well as making it much easier to find one. The net effect could be fewer people driving their own cars and an overall net reduction of cars on the road. Though I think better, ubiquitous mass transit would do far more in that direction, though the infrastructure costs for that are enormous: The figure $1 billion per mile of rail comes to mind. Better bus transit might work much better though for cheaper.
- DennisP 7y agoWhy should we ignore Uber and Lyft? They exist, they do the same job, and they don't seem to be making the roads any more clogged than they were already. So maybe they show that in practice, we don't need medallions after all.