5 ms·
This isn't the best article, but there's a point that I think is useful: > What the ordinary person might interpret as a con game or sheer lunacy, the heavily
by wpietri 7y ago
This isn't the best article, but there's a point that I think is useful:
> What the ordinary person might interpret as a con game or sheer lunacy, the heavily credentialed investor, with his TED Talk understanding of things, will reliably regard as brilliant eccentricity.
When people hear about typical con games, like the Pigeon Drop [1], their reaction is often, "Thank goodness I'm so smart I'll never fall for a con!" But that's incorrect. Maybe I wouldn't fall for that con, but that just means the con wasn't for me.
Things like Theranos and WeWork fooled people who were plenty smart. But they are, like everybody, trying to model the world using 3 pounds of meat. It's not enough. We take shortcuts. And all of those shortcuts have flaws.
One of our industry's collective flaws is a belief in the genius, that revolutionary smart guy who's just so smartily smart that they see things the ordinaries don't, and will therefore be very successful. But that leaves us vulnerable to people who perform the tropes of genius. Hands up everybody who's had to work with an "architect" like that.
Another is of course the genius entrepreneur, who has a grand vision to transform the world. As we can see, investors just love that. They've been trained to love it by all the "genius entrepreneur" stories that are generated by finding somebody successful and then filling in the narrative mad-lib with events from their lives. And of course, finding that "genius" entrepreneur lets investors see themselves as geniuses of a different kind. It lets investors justify their belief they deserve to be super rich.
Let's hope things like Uber and Theranos and WeWork put enough holes in that myth that we'll stop being vulnerable to people who put on the genius outfit and do the genius performance. Because personally, I've been tired of it for years.
[1] https://abc7news.com/news/vallejo-man-loses-$10000-in-pigeon-drop-scam/801976/ https://abc7news.com/news/vallejo-man-loses-$10000-in-pigeon...
- harryh 7y agoI think it's pretty unfair to lump Uber (which really has transformed the world in a real way) with Theranos (outright fraud) and WeWork (possibly a viable but semi boring business that got way over hyped).
- wpietri 7y agoHave you read "Super Pumped"? I'm pretty comfortable putting them in the same bucket: which is "genius/asshole founder hyping an unlikely future to get gobs of venture capital". Uber still hasn't turned a profit, and may never because it has no moat. I expect that in ~15 years, Uber will be in the same bucket as Groupon: things that everybody was excited about for a while but are at best minor players in their space. I also think you're giving Uber way too much credit. They are the dominant player because Kalanick was unusually terrible and because his investors gave a terrible person a lot of money. He didn't invent remote taxi dispatch (which was a telephone-era innovation) and he wasn't first in the anybody-with-a-car-can-be-a-taxi game (which was Lyft). He was just more willing to break laws and be a dick to competitors. I believe that if Uber hadn't appeared on the scene, things would be about the same (by which I mean we'd have people ordering rides via smartphone) but in a healthier way (by which I mean not burning billions per year, less worker exploitation, fewer negative externalities, and healthier municipal regulation). So I'll give plenty of credit to the smartphone pioneers, especially Palm and Apple. But not much to Kalanick.
- harryh 7y agoI think the Kalanick you describe here is a ruthless businessman that veers across the line into asshole and that's...not great. But again, it's not the same thing as Holmes (fraudster) or Neumann (purveyor of fantastical bullshit).
- wpietri 7y agoTime will tell. Uber and WeWork are both bets on the ability to get monopoly-level pricing power on a major chunk of economic activity, just like Google and Facebook did. Neither one has a valuation that makes sense without that pricing power, and both of have been trying to buy it via liberal application of investor money. But in both cases, they've never turned a profit and there's no obvious moat. I agree that WeWork's vision is now more obviously likely to fail than Uber's. But WeWork's transition from hero to goat happened quite recently. Uber got a cash infusion from their IPO that gives them something like 18 months runway, but with their stock down 30% from IPO, they can't do that forever. We'll see what happens when they have to break even. Especially if they have to start paying their workers fairly. And if the margins in that business turn sufficiently positive, I expect people will be eager to compete. And even if they do manage to pull it together, I'm still comfortable putting Uber in that category, as Kalanick wasn't just an asshole, but a willful criminal who got his money through the same performative asshole/genius shtick. He may ultimately get away with it. But I think he's decreased the likelihood people will fall for it again.
- fouc 7y agoGood point. I was going to ask why OP mentioned Uber.
- nabdab 7y agoUber didn’t transform the World. They offered cheaper taxis. Now wework actually transformed the world by bringing cheaper and flashier rental office space which has revolutionized the way most people use rental office space... /s Though in truth, neither did anything of notice. They used VC to undercut the market in a non-sustainable fashion.
- harryh 7y agoTaxis only really worked in a few large US cities before Uber. Now I can get an Uber almost anywhere.
- Retric 7y agoUber coverage is still fairly limited with plenty of cab companies operating in areas they don’t. https://www.uber.com/global/en/cities/ https://www.uber.com/global/en/cities/ In 2012 there where 233,900 cabs in the US which seems limited, but they would work very long hours. Uber’s actual change was mostly around increasing peak availability, but not nessisarily total availability as 1/2 of their drivers average 1 to 15 hours each week.
- harryh 7y agoI didn't check exhaustively but I looked at all the cities in South Carolina (the state that I am from) in that list and if you click through you'll see that the areas they are talking about actually pretty much cover the whole state. If that's getting done for SC (a relatively un-dense state) I think they're covering pretty much everywhere in the US. TBH I think the page you linked to is more about SEO than about Uber's actual coverage. Can you tell me a specific place that has good coverage from cabs where Uber doesn't operate?
- Retric 7y agoFor larger areas I am not seeing Charleston WV on their list of cities. Though this would be easier if they showed a single map across the US. Think smaller, Charles town WV official population 5,957 has taxi service. Edit: that was under the Baltimore map even though DC was closer. https://www.uber.com/global/en/cities/baltimore/ https://www.uber.com/global/en/cities/baltimore/
- CPLX 7y agoUber wasn’t really what transformed the world, it was just an emergent property. What changed taxi transportation was ubiquitous personal computers with detailed screens, network connectivity, and GPS in literally everyone’s pocket. As soon as it was technically possible to press a button on a portable device you already have and see a little car coming towards you on a map, hundreds of startup founders were going to try to do it, and did. Before that something like Uber was impossible, after that it was inevitable. Just like something like YouTube and something like Netflix were inevitable. That’s not to discount the very impressive work it takes to be the winner in such a fast moving market. But it’s not reasonable to credit them with the world transforming innovation, it was just the next logical step in an ongoing progression.
- harryh 7y agoDid smartphones transform the world or were they just an emergent property of improved touchscreen and battery technology? Like...I get what you are saying and I agree that something like Uber was inevitable. But someone still has to go out and do it.
- bhouston 7y agoEvery big business idea in inevitable in it's time. The trick is being first to grow large and take the market. Often people try out the exact same ideas but they are too soon so they run into problems. Timing matters so much as well as the ability to raise money when it is a big idea Your argument means no business success deserves any credit, they all just inevitable .
- CPLX 7y agoNah. Some businesses are genuinely innovative from a technical or structural standpoint. Ford comes to mind, or Google. They had very strong competitive advantages due to a technically superior process or product. Cars and search engines were probably inevitable, but Ford and Google moved the technology forward a whole generation. Uber made a pretty rudimentary mobile application, their real competitive advantage had more to do with success in financial sophistication and compliance/regulatory avoidance.
- rossdavidh 7y agoAlso, I have to point out that, like the "pigeon drop", this kind of appeal to VC's relies on their greed overwhelming their skepticism. If you really, really want it to be true (that you are about to get much richer), it's easier to convince yourself that it's true. Which makes it even easier for the one gaming you to be convincing; they really just have to get out of the way an allow you to convince yourself. If you're not desperately trying to convince yourself that this is an opportunity to make a lot of money, it's not so convincing.
- fouc 7y agoIt's awkward when "smart" people rely on the virtue signalling of other "smart" people in order to make the assumption they're smart.
- pytester 7y agoThis is a little more than just a matter of the intrinsic fallibility of human nature. There's also a structural flaw in capitalism itself that allows these massive wastes of resources to be perpetuated: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greater_fool_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greater_fool_theory
- solipsism 7y agoI don't think it's fair to call this a flaw in capitalism. Valuations are only as rational as the fallible humans making valuation decisions. Imagining a capitalist system composed of all rational actors, this problem would disappear completely. This isn't a structural flaw in capitalism, that's expecting too much of capitalism.
- pytester 7y ago>Imagining a capitalist system composed of all rational actors, this problem would disappear completely. Yes, because it's pretty easy to imagine a functioning social system based upon people not being people. >that's expecting too much of capitalism. That irrational behavior in the wasteful allocation of resources doesn't generate a negative feedback loop that causes even more waste?
- solipsism 7y agoThat irrational behavior in the wasteful allocation of resources doesn't generate a negative feedback loop that causes even more waste? Who said it didn't? I think you're missing my point. The irrational behavior is a flaw. But it's not fair to call it a structural flaw of capitalism. The flaw is prior to capitalism. It's like saying toilets are flawed because people piss on the seat.
- wpietri 7y agoIt's definitely a flaw in capitalism, because we concentrate decision-making control for large sums of capital (that is, yesterday's labor [1]) in the hands of a small number of people. And quite often those people are irrationally greedy sociopaths who are comfortable with, say, burning billions of dollars on the off chance that it will get them very rich. Of course, no decision-making apparatus is perfect. Our current version of capitalism with all its flaws might be the optimal way to run a society. But we should be clear-eyed about those flaws. [1] https://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/abraham_lincoln_395631 https://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/abraham_lincoln_395631
- mdorazio 7y agoTo me, a big part of the problem is that investors are all trying to find the next super unicorn to make their fund numbers work out, so there’s a built-in incentive to bet on big visions even when they’re likely to be bullshit. This gets compounded by the fact that you don’t actually have to build a sustainable company, you just have to pump it long enough to get your investment return courtesy of the public markets and then who cares about the company’s fate? See, for example, Groupon. I distinctly remember doing a startup incubator back when it was about to IPO and everyone was breathlessly encouraging us to be more like Groupon. The VC model is fundamentally susceptible to this stuff.