3 ms·
On the other hand, just because MKUltra existed, it doesn't follow that it was successful and that the CIA can control your mind through your television and thr
by krapp 7y ago
On the other hand, just because MKUltra existed, it doesn't follow that it was successful and that the CIA can control your mind through your television and through chemicals in the food and water supply. Yet "tinfoil" people assume the latter from the former almost universally.
Let's not abandon the premise that extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof in favor of assuming that any conspiracy theory, however outlandish, should be assumed correct simply because some conspiracies have been proven to exist in the past. People don't doubt "tinfoil hat people" because of who they are, but because they don't care to present evidence to back up their claims, or accept evidence to the contrary.
- dijit 7y agoBut let’s take the original premise: the US government wanted a means of controlling how people thought. Do you believe they abandoned that pursuit after a failed experiment 50 years ago? Do you believe they abandoned it forever?
- krapp 7y ago>Do you believe they abandoned that pursuit after a failed experiment 50 years ago? I believe direct mind control of that sort is infeasible, certainly likely impossible at the scale of entire populations, so I do believe they abandoned that specific pursuit after discovering that the human brain and LSD didn't work the way they hoped. The government also looked into remote viewing and psychic assassinations, but I don't believe they just kept on trying that either. >Do you believe they abandoned it forever? The goal? Probably not. The means? Probably. I believe it's more effective in modern society to influence people through disinformation campaigns and popular culture, particularly though social media, than attempt to control them like puppets by secretly dosing them with LSD and barbiturates.
- mistermann 7y ago> I believe it's more effective in modern society to influence people through disinformation campaigns and popular culture, particularly though social media, than attempt to control them like puppets by secretly dosing them with LSD and barbiturates. I agree. What's interesting about LSD though is that it can provide extremely useful insight into the underlying nature of beliefs, or how an individual came to believe certain things, or why they feel a certain way. Knowing more of these details seems like it would be extremely useful in the development of propaganda campaigns.
- ncmncm 7y agoIndeed, Guantanamo victims do not report drug use. But the widespread, in some cases (Ted Koppel, Tom Friedman) rabid support for the Iraq debacle is prima facie evidence for its continued use.
- PavlovsCat 7y agoWhenever I see stuff like https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21164686 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21164686 I think of > If both the past and the external world exist only in the mind, and if the mind itself is controllable – what then? -- George Orwell Similar for "brain/machine interface to help paralyzed people", to be perfectly blunt. I don't mean it's all just a cute narrative to get the tech going, but the thought that the same centers of power and wealth, that have no problem bombing people so they're dead or paralyzed or whatever_we_dont_actually_care_besides_PR_fallout, might truly care about helping the paralyzed... I can't buy that, or anything like it. Most individual researchers, all but very few, have benign intentions and awesome aspirations, I'm sure, but overall, reading and writing the mind is just too temping to not override all the nice words and hopes when it gets within reach and push comes to shove. I'd say it's a very old desire, which simply hasn't let up. It's not restricted to the US governments or governments in general either, any small cult does it, every abuser in a relationship does, in a low-tech way.
- leetcrew 7y agoeither way, does it change how you live your life? do you monitor the people you know for signs of mind control? do you start an activist movement to stop something you're not sure exists?