16 ms·
They don't like that you can rip it and then play it back on whatever machines you want, forever. They want to be able to sell you the same content over and ove
by cortesoft 7y ago
They don't like that you can rip it and then play it back on whatever machines you want, forever. They want to be able to sell you the same content over and over again... either via streaming subscription, or via a new format when it comes out.
- pkulak 7y agoI guess that's possible, but I've bought 100s of videos and movies online and never lost access for a second. Probably bought my first one 15+ years ago. I've probably lost half my physical media and hard drives, however.
- cortesoft 7y agoSounds like you have been lucky picking retailers for your online purchases... there have been numerous stories about retailers going out of business and taking their DRM servers offline. Interestingly, I have never lost hard drive data in 25 years or so... I am pretty meticulous in my backups.
- scarface74 7y agoThere is only one digital video store that I’m aware of that went out of business and they allowed you to transfer your content. If you buy movies from the four major studios that support Movies Anywhere and you connect your accounts, you can purchase on Google Play, Amazon Prime, Apple, or Vudu and they are credited to each of your accounts. That being said, I wouldn’t buy digital movies either. I will rent them.
- mguerville 7y agoSeveral music streaming providers have trimmed their catalogs and then I discovered that songs in my playlists were removed. I never got a warning saying by the way these x many songs you like and pay a monthly rent for are being removed, they just did it.
- scarface74 7y agoThat’s a completely different scenario. You aren’t paying to own the music you are paying to “rent it”. Digital music you buy hasn’t been DRM encumbered for a decade. When have you “bought” digital music or movies and lost access to them?
- skinnymuch 7y agoYeah but has iTunes ever done that to you for music you bought? Streaming catalogues aren’t the same thing.
- pkulak 7y agoYeah, I did the math on backups and it doesn't make sense. I had a terrabyte or so of my Blue-Ray backups and even using Glacier it was enough to just buy a digital movie every month or so. Now I probably have 5-10 terrabytes in digital products. Just checked prices again and it's at $4 a month for a terrabyte, which is less, but I'd still just rather rent/buy than pay for backups.
- shakna 7y agoThere's that, but there's also the cost of manufacturing and distributing the physical media. It needs cover designs, labeling, menu design, people expect features like commentaries, etc. Or, you can invest nothing extra, and the majority of your audience will still engage with the product. The cost/benefit analysis doesn't point to physical media as worth it.
- avian 7y agoI never understood why they had video media ship their own UI. It’s usually annoying to figure out and sometimes absolutely idiotic (like The Fifth Element that forces you to “catch” menu entries by timing your keypresses). It’s like if music CD would have you argue with the band before you could hear the music, instead of just pressing “play”.
- johnchristopher 7y agoOh, I can shed some light on that ! In another life I did a stint in the subtitle industry (right around the glorious DVD boom and before the arrival of Blue-Ray). Execs from distributors would sit down in a room once a movie had been subbed and played around the UI to see if "every language can be selected". How to spice up that job and make it look like indispensable ? Become an UI expert in the shades of faux shadow TIFF pictures overlay and timing in sound loop in menus. The fact that magazines were grading DVD's menus and UI also helped. "It's part of the experience". From then on you could not not provide fancy menus. The funny part ? We had to purposefully disable built-in functionalities (soundtrack switching, subtitles switching, scene skipping, etc.) to enforce some "entertaining" loading times (and the usual anti-piracy scheme). So that the exec can sit in the room discussing for three hours how a menu DVD should look and sound to "give a mood". Rinse and repeat, you got a job. Fun fact: the whole operation relied heavily on DVD shrink which we used to remove those limitations. Some took the habit to introduce hidden code to disable stuff or still allow skipping. I am a bit bitter about it but I acknowledge that for most people it's part of the experience and it's expected. But forcing it on people who don't like it ? Bummer. edit: I don't remember the name of the major software used to produce DVD menus (it was a tool chain anyway) (sonic something ?) but it was horrible compared to flash and flash mx from the mid 2000's. Think: timeline, b-frame based loop, on a slow media, still frame for background, simple transparent overlay TIFF files to render highlighted menu items, the editor was basically a vid and audio track editor with loops and skip points. No code. Mac and Windows versions not compatible. Adobe had a good hobbyist software but there were small showstoppers problems I can't remember. Anyway, it went all downhill really fast as the money needed to get a studio on track to do the authoring went from hundred of thousand of euros for hardware to a PC with early NAS and cheap HDD. A guy could set up his own subtitling and authoring studio on a dime. But you needed connections with distributors to make some money.
- scarface74 7y agoI don’t think they care about ripping. So few people buy DVDs now and any that aren’t sold are returned to the manufacturer.
- lawn 7y agoWhy is this even a concern? You can easily find it all online on torrent sites anyway. Not saying you're wrong, I just don't understand.