5 ms·
It seems somewhat silly to only talk about the negative aspects of cars. What about all the benefits? If you stop and think about it, cars are truly revolutio
by refurb 7y ago
It seems somewhat silly to only talk about the negative aspects of cars. What about all the benefits?
If you stop and think about it, cars are truly revolutionary. Even many low income people can buy a machine that will travel 50 miles (at 70 mph) on a gallon of liquid that costs $3.
It not only allows individuals the freedom to travel, vehicles power a massive transportation network that brings food to our tables and a ton of consumer goods to our local stores.
I would argue the automobile is one of the greatest technological inventions of the past 200 years.
- bproven 7y agoI think the main problem is that cars can be a great last mile transport but a horribly scaling transport for common long distance travel (commuting to city cores, etc).
- bluGill 7y agoCars are great for long distance travel. They do well for medium distances in some situations and are terrible for last mile. When my family wants to go to grandma's (or any other vacation destination) our car is the best way to do it. The key here is a family - we fill our car so per passenger we use less fuel (carbon), the train or bus could do better but because the route isn't direct it isn't that great of a win - and they need to be full to compete which they might not be. For medium distances (less than 50 miles) they do great if and only if there are few other people going the same way. Which is to say rural and non-dense areas. However because they are such low occupancy in denser areas the congestion and storage needs when you get there get you. For last mile the storage needs at both ends means that even though they seem great they just spread the places you want to get to farther than if you didn't have a car and just walked. In suburban areas we ignore this because there is no place within walking distance you would want to get to anyway. Note that the key to long distances is far enough that you wouldn't do this normally. If everybody's grandma (or vacation spot...) lived in the same neighborhood as mine this would fail - but then the bus/train would be a direct route and so it would be practical.
- kiba 7y agoIt appeared that our man-made environment expanded to fit the requirement and capabilities of the car rather than the other way around.
- bluGill 7y agoOur ability to travel allowed us to do that though. Instead of living in crowded slums the poor can afford to get out a little bit, it might not be much but I see poor people with a garden in their own yard - a yard that before the car the almost rich would have instead.
- WilliamEdward 7y agoThat's not a hard argument to make, at all. The world pre and post car is a completely different place. That said, the step towards Self Driving Cars will not be even close to the same level of revolutionary, and so discussing the negative aspects is important here so we don't have an 'ends justify the means' situation on our hands.
- AndrewKemendo 7y agoI feel like this goes without saying. I doubt there are more than a few people would argue with anything you wrote above. The trends are basically flat to declining long term for deaths, alongside significant growth in total miles driven - indicating things are consistently getting safer for everyone. So the author is clearly cherry picking data with anecdotes. The author doesn't even attempt to have a measured argument here and I think this is an example of how people are thinking "both extremes" need be heard but just assuming the "cars are revolutionary" is the extreme on the other side.
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>just assuming the "cars are revolutionary" is the extreme on the other side. You don't need to assume though because you can look at history. Regardless of whether you think it is good or bad cars changed how we live in a large way. I think they fit the definition of revolutionary.
- marble-drink 7y agoYeah, we've celebrated that for the past 50 years or so. It's time to move on. The bicycle is a far greater invention. Cars are not sustainable.
- corodra 7y agoYea, but you're not going to get a book shelf to your house using a bike. Or a lot of groceries for the family. If your 8-year breaks his arm, a car of some sort makes that easier to get to the hospital instead of waiting for an ambulance. Oh, just a big pack of toilet paper. That's kind of awkward on a bike. Kind of sucks when it rains or snows. Then you also have to carry around/use more deodorant per month so you don't smell bad at the office.
- egypturnash 7y agoAnd food is optimized solely to be easy to transport and look good on a store shelf after a long ride rather than be healthy. And burning that liquid is one of the top contributors of global warming. For a good while we were adding lead to that liquid in the name of a better burn, despite knowing for much longer than that that lead is terrible for organic creatures like ourselves. And restructuring cities around cars has ripped out highly functional, happy neighborhoods, and brought us the suburb, with its vast expanses of identical houses miles and miles away from anything even remotely interesting, and it’s immense hostility to someone who doesn’t have a car (and it’s denizens’ immense hostility to anyone spending their tax money on improving public transit).
- redblacktree 7y agoYou've painted with a pretty broad brush here; a lot of this isn't true. I suppose "remotely interesting" is a matter of opinion, but I live in a suburb that has its own "downtwon" and other amenities, to include a performance art theatre, beautiful plaza with ping pong tables, big screen TV, outdoor pool tables, etc. It's really pretty awesome if you have kids. It's also a subrub that isn't hostile to people who don't own cars. It's entirely practical to get around by bicycle. I guess the bottom line is: the hyperbole doesn't really serve your argument.
- theelous3 7y agoWhat you find interesting (some stuff for kids and some shops in a purpose built suburban plaza / mall) is likely not going to be found interesting by someone who lives in an actual city. I wouldn't consider what they said to be total hyperbole. It seems that way to you, because you're happy where you are, but that isn't for everyone. Also, by suburban standards, yours sounds like an outlier on the good side, and I still wouldn't live there. Most people don't have a nice plaza and so on thoughtfully built for their mass housing.
- idreyn 7y agoI would argue that the automobile is a brilliantly designed tool for making flexible, medium-long distance trips quickly and cheaply. In America, this tool has been stretched far beyond the use cases where it shines. We've tried to make it "the only mode you'll ever need" for almost all Americans, deploying it where transit, cycling, and walking would be far more appropriate. It is great that many low-income people can technically afford to own a vehicle; it is not great that the layout of our cities _forces_ them to own and maintain one.
- toper-centage 7y agoAlso neglecting long distance transit. Passenger trains are pretty much not a thing in America, right?
- bluGill 7y agoPassenger trains suck at long distance transit. Trains work well for trips up to around 500 miles where they are faster than planes after factoring arriving at the airport early, after that trains are more expensive and slower than airplanes, without allowing the flexibility of a car. Note that if you live in Europe you can cover several countries in this distance and thus feel well traveled without ever going far from home on a continental (much less global) scale. A full car is cost competitive with planes and trains, and gives you flexibility to stop and see things along the way.
- gwbas1c 7y agoNot really, the distances are too great to make them economical. That's why air travel is more common. For distances where trains make sense, cars are preferable: You can travel at your own schedule, and then you have transportation at your destination. If you take a train, you have to meet the train at a certain place at a certain time, which is stressful, and then you still have to arrange transportation from the train station to your final destination. Even worse, if you have to change trains during your trip... It's much, much easier to put all your stuff in a car once. This basically leaves trains for traveling between dense cities, where the passengers either live close to a train station, or have a destination close to a train station. And, to be honest, after flying twice with young kids this year, I put my foot down and told my wife road trips only for the next few years. I wouldn't want to travel by train with young children for the same reason that travel by air with young children is difficult.