3 ms·
I would very much love to agree with you. But London’s public transportation system, while very good considering its age and the extensiveness of deployment is
by dijit 7y ago
I would very much love to agree with you. But London’s public transportation system, while very good considering its age and the extensiveness of deployment is not perfect; it is not a stretch to call it overburdened.
I lived there for 5 years and absolutely dreaded commuting.
A quick win would be to prevent the morning and evening rush. But that’s another discussion entirely.
- lifeisstillgood 7y agoIf you have ideas on how to prevent that daily nightmare there are 10 million pairs of ears ready to listen :-)
- ddalex 7y agoI've done the London commute for 6 years now. My solution : work out flexible hours with my employer. If I have the stand-up at 11 I can jump in the underground at 9:30, after the worst of the rush is done. Likewise in the evening, work until the worst of the rush is done. My SO solution: live in the city, work on the outskirts. The commute is effectively against the traffic. Can get a seat and plenty of space at 8:30, top of the rush hour. There are some solutions but I'm not sure that they scale, though.
- close04 7y agoTrams are actually a strange beast that's not as cheap and flexible as a bus, and not as efficient as the underground but still quite expensive to build and maintain, which is the main reason many cities abandoned them. A big advantage is that they are electric but once electric buses really take off they'll be a much better compromise for public transport overall. Much of the surface traffic would have to be reduced anyway.
- bobthepanda 7y agoThe main advantage of trams over a bus is that in general, the layout is more conducive for rapid boarding and alighting, and the trams can physically be longer and have more room for people. The main advantage of trams over an underground is that they can be much cheaper to build. Crossrail 2 in London is expected to cost 32 billion GBP; you could build quite a lot of tram for that kind of money.
- bluGill 7y agoOnly the fact that trams can be larger is inherent in trams. The rest could easily be applied to a bus if someone had the vision to do so.
- elsurudo 7y agoIt's not always _just_ about objective features. I really like trams and trains in general, because they feel "solid" – like an immovable part of the city infrastructure. There are mental benefits to this, I feel. Buses jostle around, abrupty change speeds, etc. Trams... just glide. You are on a movable walkway, seeing the cityscape unfold on both sides as you commute to work.
- asdff 7y agoTrams do not glide. The trams in portland sound like nails on the chalkboard when they round a turn. They also vibrate and thud and have to deal with traffic all the same if they aren't grade separated.
- ACow_Adonis 7y agoThe on-boarding/off-boarding efficiency of trams would be very hard to replicate in a bus design. Low floor and equivalent disabled access would be hard too. The efficiency of metal on metal movement is harder to match with buses. Big heavy vehicles on bitumen and rubber particulate have environmental costs and maintenance costs (I haven't looked at this one, but people frequently ignore that tyres themselves being used create air particulate pollution). You can have the equivalent shared pedestrian zone with a tram: search Bourke st mall Melbourne or watch how pedestrians jaywalk with abandonment down Brunswick st Fitzroy that you can't get with heavy rail because of the start/stopping times, and that you don't get with buses because pedestrians don't have the psychological certainty of their travel direction and momentum. And lastly there is a real psychological town planning point with fixed rail that sees density and value build up around better around permanent paths and installments. It's well and good to dismiss that as someone could do it differently if they wanted to, but its arguing using "shoulds and coulds" against empirical reality.
- lonelappde 7y agoIn the US the only thing that stopped municipal trams was bribes from auto manufacturers
- asdff 7y agoIn LA they were run by a private company that was mandated by the city to keep fares the same as in like 1910 despite costs being far higher in the 1950s. Service was cut and cut and ridership therefore fell and fell until the company folded and the city ripped out nearly all the rails. By contrast, nearly the exact same thing happened in NYC. All the trains there were private, went bankrupt, but the city bought and expanded the system instead of tearing it out.
- kijin 7y agoOf course it's far from perfect. It's an ancient, organically grown city that contains roughly the same number of people as the entire country of Switzerland. Instead of romancitizing about European cities that are 1/20 of their size, I wish Londoners and New Yorkers would look to China and Japan for better examples. Those guys know how to build and maintain 21st century infrastructure for millions.
- Symbiote 7y agoTransport For London itself doesn't look to small cities. They even offer consulting to large cities (Hong Kong, Sydney, Boston) to share their experience. https://tfl.gov.uk/info-for/business-and-commercial/commercial-consulting https://tfl.gov.uk/info-for/business-and-commercial/commerci...
- simongray 7y ago> Those guys know how to build and maintain 21st century infrastructure for millions. Maybe Japan? Haven't visited. But China has lots of terrible city planning and they are way too into cars. I lived in Beijing for 2 years and Beijing traffic is just the worse. Beijing is also not a very good city to be a pedestrian in, as every major street typically has 12-16 lanes and waiting at intersections takes forever. It feels like walking along a motorway. Finding shortcuts throughs the alleyways of a city block is also really hard as many of them are gated. Same goes for any major Chinese city really, except for the ones with surviving colonial city centres like Shanghai. The metro is pretty good, but definitely not pleasant to use during rush hour, and changing lines usually entails a lot of walking around underground tunnels.