9 ms·
Interestingly London had one of the most extensive tram systems in Europe, but sadly it was mostly abolished in favour of the Car because: 1) cars = freedom 2
by dijit 7y ago
Interestingly London had one of the most extensive tram systems in Europe, but sadly it was mostly abolished in favour of the Car because:
1) cars = freedom
2) trams are for the poor
A good little mini-doc by Jay Foreman spells it out nicely: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ji3C_PjJonM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ji3C_PjJonM
Interestingly, a very similar story in the UK surrounding bicycles. :\
I wouldn't call Zurichs streets perfect though; by sheer coincidence I spent the majority of today exploring the city for the first time in my life and was very confused on how to cross the road at a lot of very ill-thought-out junctions. And there are still a lot of very loud cars on the road.
However; I will admit there is a "feeling" when walking through the city that it was well thought out in general, I felt like I had a lot of space and I didn't get the same claustrophobic feeling I get in NYC or the cramped "intruded" feeling I get in London.
- kijin 7y agoLondon still has one of the most extensive underground railway systems in the world, as well as the most iconic buses. Notwithstanding the nostalgia that we often associate with them, trams are not a magical method of transportation. Nothing of value is lost if you can get the same job done with trains underground and buses above. Underground railways have the additional benefit of not taking up precious urban space that could be used by e.g. bicycles. It just happens that digging tunnels is much more expensive than embedding a pair of rails in the pavement, so cities have to think harder about short-term costs vs. long-term benefits.
- dijit 7y agoI would very much love to agree with you. But London’s public transportation system, while very good considering its age and the extensiveness of deployment is not perfect; it is not a stretch to call it overburdened. I lived there for 5 years and absolutely dreaded commuting. A quick win would be to prevent the morning and evening rush. But that’s another discussion entirely.
- lifeisstillgood 7y agoIf you have ideas on how to prevent that daily nightmare there are 10 million pairs of ears ready to listen :-)
- ddalex 7y agoI've done the London commute for 6 years now. My solution : work out flexible hours with my employer. If I have the stand-up at 11 I can jump in the underground at 9:30, after the worst of the rush is done. Likewise in the evening, work until the worst of the rush is done. My SO solution: live in the city, work on the outskirts. The commute is effectively against the traffic. Can get a seat and plenty of space at 8:30, top of the rush hour. There are some solutions but I'm not sure that they scale, though.
- close04 7y agoTrams are actually a strange beast that's not as cheap and flexible as a bus, and not as efficient as the underground but still quite expensive to build and maintain, which is the main reason many cities abandoned them. A big advantage is that they are electric but once electric buses really take off they'll be a much better compromise for public transport overall. Much of the surface traffic would have to be reduced anyway.
- bobthepanda 7y agoThe main advantage of trams over a bus is that in general, the layout is more conducive for rapid boarding and alighting, and the trams can physically be longer and have more room for people. The main advantage of trams over an underground is that they can be much cheaper to build. Crossrail 2 in London is expected to cost 32 billion GBP; you could build quite a lot of tram for that kind of money.
- bluGill 7y agoOnly the fact that trams can be larger is inherent in trams. The rest could easily be applied to a bus if someone had the vision to do so.
- iguy 7y agoBesides cost there is also time. Many of London's lines are very deep, and so it takes significant time just to get down there & back up again.
- razzimatazz 7y agoBeing on the surface adds a lot of value for short trips in a tram (or similar). To reach the subway takes 2-4 minutes of travel down to platform level and back up. To cross the car lane to the tram station in Zurich takes 10-30s if you see the tram coming or read the digital signage, and a few minutes later you can be at your intended destination. Zurich has of course large parking garages, and if you bring your car in to the city you would leave it there and be able to hop around on the trams & buses, taking only a few minutes between your different shopping and eating destinations. I also think as a wealthy car driver you can differentiate yourself from the poor public-transport-dependents by choosing to stand on the tram, showing off your high-end branded shopping bags.
- skummetmaelk 7y agoTrams have the advantage of not being blocked by traffic. You can achieve the same with dedicated bus lanes, but motorists don't always respect those and they take more space.
- dsego 7y agoNot all trams have dedicated tracks. Usually some main lines, otherwise they share the road with cars.
- close04 7y agoThe worst part is that they share intersections with regular roads, exactly where most accidents tend to happen. And the accidents can be a bit more disruptive because a tram can easily block even bigger intersections.
- bogomipz 7y ago">Nothing of value is lost if you can get the same job done with trains underground and buses above." I would argue that seeing day light is a thing of value. Also the ability to look out a window and see life is also much more interesting than staring out into dark lifeless subway tunnels. Berlin and Amssterdam both have trams and neither seems to have impinged on space for bicycles.
- ACow_Adonis 7y agoWhy not trains underground and trams on the surface in the pedestrian environment like Melbourne CBD :p (See my other post in this thread for real benefits and design choices trams make over buses and rail)
- blue_devil 7y agoI think a cyclist would feel more safe and less gassed alongside a tram, than a bus (the majority of buses not being electric).
- JJMcJ 7y agohttps://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/2e/Los_Angeles_Pacific_Electric_Railways_%28Red_Cars%29.svg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/2e/Los_Ange... The immense streetcar network in the Los Angeles area.
- asdff 7y agoRipped out to run busses on freeways. Look at how that turned out. They were about to build an extensive subway network and grade separate many of the streetcars, but urban planners back then didn't think it would be possible for freeways to experience traffic. Now, 60 years later, we are paying out the ass and taking decades on transit builds and all there is to show for the last 25 years of LA Metro is three light rail lines (none are grade separated, are crowded and delayed during peak hours, and they take 40 minutes to go from their termini to downtown), one heavy rail line that doesn't have enough stops or short enough headways, and a stub with, once again, not enough stops or short enough headways that they've been working on extending for three years and won't finish for another 4. There is also a BRT, which was supposed to be rail and funded to be rail, but LA Metro backed down to the 50 NIMBYs in the room screeching during the public presentations instead of plugging their ears and building better transit for the hundreds of thousands living along the orange line. This city has 18 million living in the metro area and the transit system is an embarrassment. Every other major artery should have rail running underneath it by now. The whole LA basin should have a fisherman's net of trains criss crossing it by now. The only saving grace is if the federal government one day steps in and plows through these transit projects with the army corps of engineers. LA Metro is in over its head and can't be trusted to pick a contractor that isn't going to overstate, embezzle, underdeliver, then get picked for the next contract because they've made friends with the board and did just sooo well on that last project that was overbudget and behind schedule.
- JJMcJ 7y agoHeadways - I believe many Pacific Electric routes had a car every 5 minutes. Not once every 1/2 hour like a lot of light rail. As somebody besides me put it, if you have to check the schedule it's not a real transit system.
- TulliusCicero 7y agoSame thing in Munich. It feels pleasant to just walk around in a way that I haven't found in the US. Some US cities are reasonably walkable (e.g. SF, NYC, Boston), but they don't really feel nice to walk around like Munich. Munich manages to be fairly dense -- at least by American standards -- without feeling crowded.
- ACow_Adonis 7y agoWell, part of that non- cramped feeling comes from the fact that it's a city that's almost an order of magnitude smaller than London or NYC. I'm a little bit torn because honestly, Zurich was one of my least favorite places in Europe: subjectively very sterile and boring. Fortunately I've been to Zurich, London and Melbourne. Melbourne's inner city streets have good practical examples of all modes (tram, subway/heavy rail/car/pedestrian... limited separated bike priority examples though) as a practical study available in terms of street design and with a larger population, albeit still not as large as NYC or London. An example of tram priority is available on street views of Collins st and Nicholson st Melbourne with a higher population. But we're still in a country/city with car culture as well. Local experience here suggests that you still get this weird psychological effect: the number of people who have proclaimed to me the "wasted space" of the street down Collins is staggering, even though i would argue by objective accounts Melbourne CBD compared to Sydney CBD is a visible success story of pedestrian priority, vitality, and design. And when you sit down and actually do the numbers (as in physically count) these 'wasted streets' are moving more people than cars or buses on equivalent roads. You also get this weird effect of out of towners or suburbanites proclaiming the superiority of buses: which I can't disagree more strongly with, and again point out that the areas with trams are bustling with life, value, density and services (it seems pretty objective to me to say the main problems/ limits is the traffic, not the trams) relative to the areas that many of these critiques come from, and yet there's a ststrange urge for outsiders to "fix" them with suggestions of cars/buses and how there's "wasted space" in the densest and most commercially and culturally successful parts of the city (with little introspective insight that the two might be fundamentally connected in some way). Plus there's another side benefit: emergency vehicles can actually get where they need to go at all times of the day: rush hour, dead of night, doesn't matter, fire engines and ambulances can drive down these swerving around the trams. Good luck doing that on a non dedicated tram line during peak hour...
- lonelappde 7y agoIt's near tautological that tram is better for people who live and work and sleep at tram stops, and worse for people who don't.
- gok 7y agoThey were also very effectively replaced with expanded rapid transit, regional rail, and buses, all of which carry many more passenger than trams ever did.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]