4 ms·
Because encryption is math and knowledge. Banning it will only stop legitimate users while bad actors can still just go ahead and encrypt their stuff. If polit
by atoav 7y ago
Because encryption is math and knowledge. Banning it will only stop legitimate users while bad actors can still just go ahead and encrypt their stuff.
If politicians consider leaving everybody vulnerable to catch criminals, this is a incredibly high price to pay. I’d argue that the price is so high that even with evidence that this would help catch criminals we should still consider not doing it. However there is no evidence for that and my argument above explains why criminals would still be able to encrypt.
We should really stop implementing any security legislation without checking whether it actually achieves the stated goals.
- KerryJones 7y agoI agree -- this is my fundamental disagreement with many laws that are in place. When they penalty to the good-actor is so severe to catch a small minority of bad-actors, it's a poor choice. I do believe we should search for solutions, I don't believe that we should let a small % of bad actors control our lives.
- anonymousDan 7y agoCounterpoint (playing devil's advocate) - if we ban e2e encryption platforms (or require a backdoor), then anyone found to be using a non backdoored tool is suspicious, reducing the effort required for law enforcement investigations.
- em-bee 7y agobut then how am i going to keep my ssh server safe? i get break-in attempts every second. if ssh gets a backdoor, then i guarantee you it will be exploited. intruders may not care about my communication, but they do care about being able to access my servers, so you can not force me to use encryption with a backdoor without putting me and my company at risk. if encryption without a backdoor gets outlawed entirely i'll go out of business because i will no longer be able to run any servers.
- atoav 7y agoThis would be only true if this was a international law. In all other cases you will have a ton of people just using what the other side under a different jurisdiction uses without even knowing it has no backdoor in it. The increase in false positives that comes with this will make it an unusable heuristic to identify criminals.
- dublinben 7y agoBlackstone's ratio¹ is a cornerstone of our legal system. We forget it at our peril, for that way lies tyranny. ¹https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_ratio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_ratio