3 ms·
My guess is that it's not only about "external" improvement but also "internal". Externally, your centaur design is more stable and probably easier to design.
by probably_wrong 7y ago
My guess is that it's not only about "external" improvement but also "internal".
Externally, your centaur design is more stable and probably easier to design. It would also allow you to do some (highly specific) tasks that a boring, two-legged human could not do. Like Aimee Mullins said in her TED talk[1], this would make you not so much "disabled", but rather "super-abled".
Internally, however, you also want those using the exoskeleton to regain their feeling of belonging. That is, you don't want the to "just" walk - you also want them to walk exactly like everybody else. To quote from this book [2],
"You don’t always feel inferior, mostly just out of place. Sometimes though, you feel a pang in your chest, a bit like a short, sharp stab. You know what it is instantly…
It's there to remind you – you’ll never be quite the same, never on the same level, you’ll never have quite the same opportunities, the same privileges, the experiences and the rites of passages everyone else takes for granted.
(...) Like when you go shopping and people stare. Funny thing is, you get used to this one over time, it affects you far less than it does your friends. They hate it and stare back or make comments – “why are people so rude, you’re not a circus animal?”. You feel like saying “actually, I am” but it wouldn’t help, you just want to shop."
[1] http://www.ted.com/talks/aimee_mullins_prosthetic_aesthetics http://www.ted.com/talks/aimee_mullins_prosthetic_aesthetics
[2] https://disabilityhorizons.com/2015/09/the-truth-about-being-disabled-or-how-it-feels-to-be-an-outsider/ https://disabilityhorizons.com/2015/09/the-truth-about-being...
- avar 7y agoI'm not bound to a wheelchair, so maybe I'm full of it, but I'd think the feeling of not belonging among paraplegics has to do with not being able to fully partake in society. Go to a party and your default is to make eye contact with people's crotches and them literally looking down on you (dumb as it is, this is important to us social primates), a simple set of stairs being an insurmountable obstacle, being excluded from "able-bodied" activities etc. As compared with being in a centaur suit, now you're a superhero. "Hey Bob, you can lift half a ton, can you help me with this?". Making good fun of your out of shape "able-bodied" buddies on a hike as you carry all their backpacks on your back etc. Of course much of that could also be said about a bipedal suit, but those are presumably harder to develop, and need to be more compact, so power storage is more of an issue, and can't as naturally transition to wheeled travel without all the issues with a Segway. It would be unfortunate to delay deployment of these systems because of some perceived prejudice against four or eight-legged systems. People at the supermarket already wear what could be called "unnatural" partial exoskeletons today. They're just called wheelchairs or mobility scooters, I don't see how a working legged contraption that doesn't pass for vanilla human when clothed would make much of a difference.