7 ms·
> it came out that she'd been removed for refusing to use people's preferred pronouns. That's not true. She was removed for asking whether, after the not-yet-c
by luckylion 7y ago
> it came out that she'd been removed for refusing to use people's preferred pronouns.
That's not true. She was removed for asking whether, after the not-yet-current CoC was made official (which asks to use preferred pronouns) it would be allowed to use third person pronouns to circumvent the issue. Neither was preferred pronoun-usage a rule, nor had she disobeyed that rule (yet).
- danaris 7y agoIf you don't know someone's gender or preferred pronouns, it's reasonable to use "they/them". If someone has explicitly asked you to use "she/her", and you exclusively use "they/them", you are still not using that person's preferred pronouns.
- luckylion 7y agoI don't disagree on the facts, but neither was there a rule (yet) that says you have to, nor has she done that. She has asked whether it would be against the future CoC not to. No comparison is perfect, but it feels similar to me asking a cop whether it's going to be illegal to do X under the new law that is being discussed, and them arresting and charging me for doing X. Neither is X currently outlawed, nor have I committed X, I have merely inquired about the legality of X.
- shkkmo 7y agoThe StackExchange staff did clarify elsewhere that they believe the old CoC prohibits misgendering and that the CoC changes are just meant to clarify the matter. They claim she repeatedly refused to change CoC violations, she claims she was just asking about using gender neutral language. It seems to me that there were likely several misunderstandings that lead to increasingly heated discussion and then the SE staff decided to remove a moderator without following their own established process for doing so.
- luckylion 7y agoSO leaked some parts of the chat but not the relevant parts, according to a staff member that was in the chat. As the fired moderator asked for evidence, it would be easy for SO to release it. This reeks of a political firing under some pretense. Misunderstandings have been suggested by the fired moderator as well, with a plea to talk to her. According to her, they haven't been taking her calls and not replied to emails. That's consistent with their public stance, so it seems plausible to me. My pet theory: it's a "punish one, educate a hundred" move. They chose a respected moderator for a laughable offense to send a clear signal that they won't allow any amount of violation of their new rules and that reputation and contributions do not protect you. Question authority and you're gone, no matter who you are. That this comes a month after the new CEO makes me believe it's the shift to a new policy, one that runs the site not as a community, but as a product to sell to other corporations.
- iliketocomplain 7y ago"They" is plural, using it for one person is just wrong grammar. Seems unbelievable nobody at SE noticed that, makes the complete discussion a non issue.
- kaishiro 7y agoI ask this as an honest question, and not as a form of bait. But the virtue of using “they/their” is that you’re being respectful of the fact that you’re not assuming anything. My problem with this suddenly becoming offensive is that I don’t see how I’m supposed to remember the additional meta of an individual’s pronouns - I already have enough trouble remembering names! Is it not creating too much of a meta minefield for...well I’m actually not sure what the gain is. Isn’t this just looking for offense where none is intended?
- AgentME 7y agoSometimes people exclusively use "they/their" to refer to trans people who prefer "he" or "she" as a way to try to publicly demean the person's transness. This isn't a rare/theoretical occurrence. Most people understand that using "they/their" is a good default when you're talking about a specific person who you happen to not know the gender of. People get that using "they" isn't necessarily an attack, but if you for example do it in response to a message where their gender is made apparent, or if you only do it when talking about trans people, then it quickly starts looking rude.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- braindeath 7y agoWell then too bad, that is going too far. When did it become a cultural imperative to explicitly call out someone's gender. This is not the same thing as misgendering someone. It's one thing to say "he" when someone wants "she." Doing so is antagonistic. But the English language has perfectly usable neutral pronouns - "they" and "them" -- which are serviceable whenever the gender of the parties in a discussion are immaterial -- which is the majority of communication on the Internet and out in the open. I will continue to use them, thank you very much. If you explicitly ask to use "she/her" or "xyz/pqr" or whatever the hell you made up, and I am not close enough to you to care or need to care about your "gender" then really, please grow up.. the world doesn't revolve around your agenda or your identity.
- VonGallifrey 7y agoShe wanted to write in a gender-neutral style. No one should be forced to use gender pronouns. It is true that you should use the right gender pronouns if you use pronouns, but why fire her for asking about using gender-neutral writing styles in a not yet released CoC. Also: They misgendered her in the "apology".