3 ms·
This is why moderation should stick to the "clear and present danger" standard established by US courts. There has to be a credible threat of violence directed
by Animats 7y ago
This is why moderation should stick to the "clear and present danger" standard established by US courts. There has to be a credible threat of violence directed at a specific individual. "Hate speech" is too hard to distinguish from political speech. Don't try to do it in advance. Prior restraint is bad.
Banning people from being excessively annoying over a period of time is perhaps an option. That's after the fact, not before.
- icebraining 7y agoUS courts also provide other rules, such as private property, which allow people to moderate in fairly creative ways. Whereas in many of these platforms, and Twitter in particular, there's very little.
- dmurray 7y agoThis is morally defensible, but from a business point of view, the likes of Twitter need to be seen doing something about "hate speech". Specifically this means suppressing the alt-right, who are the most problematic causes of bad PR. Other groups - Burmese Islamophobes, for example - might get silenced too, but out of a desire to have consistent rules rather than a clear business need or a moral imperative to prevent genocide in Myanmar.
- derefr 7y agoOr, you can go the other way, and just ban all political speech on your platform. That’s easy too! And makes perfect sense for some platforms (e.g. ones intended mainly for children.)
- jfengel 7y agoThat may not be optimal for the site, though. Many users will leave a site before it reaches the level of violent threats. The goal of moderators (on most sites) is neither to maximize speech nor to protect people's feelings. The goal is to keep people engaged with the site, and that of necessity means balancing the people who wish to be annoying with those who will leave when their annoyance gets too high. That gets the maximum engagement, which usually goes hand in hand with maximum revenue. Even on sites whose goal is divorced from revenue, many will find that Gresham's Law of Comments applies: bad speech drives out good. Hate speech tends to drive away people from the topic at hand, because people respond to hate speech as if it were a threat, even if it isn't immediately physical violence. Responding to that dominates the conversation, and then people interested in the original conversation leave. Good user controls can help, but ultimately a site must keep its eye on the bottom line. You may have a hard time distinguishing hate speech from valid political speech, but users know when they're not enjoying the site, and leave. It's up to the site's designers to pick their target audience and encourage them to stay. And if that target audience is "everybody, including people who want to engage in hate speech", they may find that "nobody, except people who want to engage in hate speech" is what they end up with. Which may well be what they want, but for those who don't, they need to recognize that and take steps.
- otterley 7y agoWhy should the bar be so high? These are private forums, after all. If I don't want someone who exhibits antisocial behavior in my community, I shouldn't have to allow it.