3 ms·
My "truth" is not your "truth" is not someone else's "truth". None of us is wise enough to tell someone else that their truth is wrong, so expecting someone to
by h2odragon 7y ago
My "truth" is not your "truth" is not someone else's "truth". None of us is wise enough to tell someone else that their truth is wrong, so expecting someone to write software that is would be asking a bit much.
Filtering out opinions the majority doesn't want to pay to hear is simpler and more lucrative anyway.
- klyrs 7y agoThere are objective truths. It doesn't matter if you think the earth is flat. It's not. And I really wish this was a contrived example
- h2odragon 7y agoThe person who believes (or says they do) that the earth is flat, has every right to do so. I agree with you, they're objectively wrong. I find it arrogant to say they have no right to speak because of that, and will not.
- ggggtez 7y agoOk, but now replace flat earthers with people advocating and organizing meetings for people interested in joining ISIS. Why do we want a world where platforms protect videos promoting and glorifying beheadings, exactly?
- rjf72 7y agoAdvocating to join a terrorist organization, or providing support for such, is illegal. Believing or saying stupid things is generally not illegal. Equating the two is nonsensical both from an intuitive and legal stance.
- throwaway_bad 7y ago> protect videos promoting and glorifying beheadings To play devil's advocate, "objectively" these beheadings are still happening somewhere in the world. It's an undeniable truth even though you don't want to see the evidence for it. For a lot of people this is their flat earth. No evidence means it's not happening. Why not allow the content to be seen, let the world be horrified that there are people driven to become like this, and try to understand what led them to do those things?
- philipkglass 7y agoISIS and other violent groups based outside the US were indeed the catalyst for the first big wave of content removal from American platforms, as I recall it. I noticed it particularly during the Syrian Civil War. For the first few years of the war you could view combat footage on YouTube and Twitter without difficulty. Later you started to see such videos rapidly removed, particularly if they were filmed from the POV of anti-government (often some Islamist faction) forces. At the time, conservative media outlets seemed predominantly critical that American platforms weren't censoring enough content. Even if that content wasn't actually illegal to publish under US law. Here's a 2014 article from the conservative site WorldNetDaily, for example: "ISIS-branded merchandise sold on Amazon, Facebook" https://www.wnd.com/2014/09/isis-branded-merchandise-sold-on-amazon-facebook/ https://www.wnd.com/2014/09/isis-branded-merchandise-sold-on... Quotes from the article: Dave Gaubatz, author of “Muslim Mafia: Inside the Secret Underworld That’s Conspiring to Islamize America,” contends Facebook and other social media sites have a responsibility to shut down the forums used to market radical Islam and mobilize Islamic youth. “I am a defender of the U.S. Constitution but the Constitution was not designed for enemies of America,” said Gaubatz, a former U.S. Air Force investigator. “We must stop jihad online because these groups target our children through social media,” he told Fox News. ... “ISIS is more than likely not producing shirts but indirectly they are benefiting from it,” Scotty Neil, a former Green Beret who founded Operator, a clothing company geared toward special ops soldiers, told Fox News. “I don’t think that T-shirt company X is sending the Islamic State funds, but people wearing these shirts are making an outward statement and that often starts a dialogue and debate that furthers their message.”
- will_pseudonym 7y agoWhich truths are objective? Who decides that? From the spectrum of Math -> Physics -> Chemistry -> Biology -> Psychology, where do you draw the line? This isn't an easy question.
- rjf72 7y agoAs one aside on the flat Earth stuff, I think something that people do not really consider is scale. There's always going to be people that are a bit off the cusp, some intentionally and some not. So hoping for 100% on most of anything is never going to happen. So let's imagine 99.9% of Americans think the world is spherical, or oval, or whatever - not flat. That is really really good. Yet, take that 0.1% to scale. In America alone that would mean that you have 330,000 people that think the Earth is flat. On Facebook scale (2.5 billion monthly average users) that'd be all the way up to 2.5 million people. And thanks to the internet people with 'eccentric' views are more capable than ever of joining up with other people with such views. And people with these views tend to be very strongly inclined to do just that, alongside also trying to evangelize their views so much as they can - because they think they know something other people do not. This effect creates a deeply misleading image of the relative popularity of various views and values. Can you imagine a Facebook group with millions of people who genuinely think the Earth is flat, and many people popping their head up in various locations to advocate for such a view? You could have that, yet it be the case that 99.9% of people do not feel that way. Scale is a hell of a thing. And given the increasing size of various platforms, you're always going to see what you perceive to be large numbers of people with rather peculiar views and values. It in no way suggests there are actually large numbers of people with these views and values. The social media paradox stands head and shoulders above that relatively petty birthday paradox.
- Angostura 7y agoPerhaps you could give some examples of conflicting 'truths'. It seems to me that in most cases the truth can usually be untangled. This may be an unpopular view, but I'm not willing to give up on the idea of objective truths just yet.