3 ms·
>Has nationalism really killed more people? It's certainly plausible. Top 10 genocides of the 20'th century: 1: Great Leap Forward (Communist) 2: Soviet Purg
by yummyfajitas 18y ago
>Has nationalism really killed more people?
It's certainly plausible. Top 10 genocides of the 20'th century:
1: Great Leap Forward (Communist)
2: Soviet Purges/Ukrainian Famine (Communist)
3: Nazis (Nationalist)
3 (Roughly Tied): Congo Wars (Nationalist)
4: Imperial Japanese (Nationalist)
5: Pol Pot (Communist)
6: Kim (Communist)
7: Mengistu in Ethiopia (Mix of Communist and Nationalist)
8: Armenian Genocide by Turks (Nationalist)
9: Igbo genocide of Nigeria (Nationalist)
http://www.scaruffi.com/politics/dictat.html http://www.scaruffi.com/politics/dictat.html
(Note: some of these numbers are sketchy, especially towards the bottom of the list. The list also missed the Congo (WTF!), which I added.)
- jon_dahl 18y agoCan I just say "Thanks" to the Hacker News crowd? comatose_kid asked a fair question about religion and atheism, and yummyfajitas gave a fair answer. No trolls, no painful Reddit-style debates on atheism vs. religion. Let's keep this up.
- 13th 18y agoAnd one more modern crime - Iraq War http://www.nytimes.com/2004/10/29/international/europe/29casualties.html?_r=1&oref=slogin http://www.nytimes.com/2004/10/29/international/europe/29cas... And do not forget about Hiroshima... p.s. world isn't black and white.
- yummyfajitas 18y agoI only listed the top 10. Iraq and Hiroshima (FYI: Tokyo and Dresden are better examples) just don't compare in scale to the Congo, the Nazi's or even Rwanda. Also, the study your article describes (and it's followup) is seriously flawed.
- strlen 18y agoThere's plausible elements of religion being an element in #8 The Soviet regime also did have a great amount of Nationalism built into it as well. The people who are also in the "religion kills" camp will also argue (and not without good arguments) that you could call communism a religion. And of course for every single one of these genocides religion, class warfare and nationalism played a role (targetting of ethnic minorities under Pol Pot, state Shinto in Japan, Socialist and volk-Religion elements in Nazism, "communism as religion" so on). (Overall I'll tend to fall within the "nationalism kills more" camp.)