4 ms·
> Facebook can read the messages at both ends This is why I believe that end-to-end encryption is not truly useful unless the source code of the clients is pub
by dheera 7y ago
> Facebook can read the messages at both ends
This is why I believe that end-to-end encryption is not truly useful unless the source code of the clients is public, or the protocol is open.
Any closed source client can read messages at the ends, or be forced to do so by an evil government.
At the very least, they could open up XMPP compatibility again so that people could write their own open source clients for it. Australia wouldn't be able to do anything about the propagation of such open source software.
I was able to have end-to-end encryption running on top of MSN, AOL, ICQ, QQ, Facebook, Gtalk, Yahoo, and several others about 10 years ago with Pidgin and simple plugins that encrypted/decrypted messages on the fly. It's too bad they all moved selfishly to closed source walled-garden mobile apps -- it's a big step back in privacy.
- lonelappde 7y agoThe only chance at security is if you can tap your network connection at the dumb wire layer, and verify that it's encrypted with your own private key.
- greyfade 7y agoI've been bouncing around the idea of a fully decentralized end-to-end encrypted chat protocol for exactly this reason, but I've been afraid to work on it for precisely the reason this thread is being discussed. I know that if my name were attached to the project, I'd be facing all kinds of unwelcome scrutiny from the government and news agencies. I'd lose the very privacy I want to maintain by designing privacy-protecting software.
- dualboot 7y agoSignal is pretty solid. https://signal.org/ https://signal.org/
- greyfade 7y agoMaybe it is, but it's not the decentralized replacement for Discord and Teams that I envision.
- cyphar 7y agoI would take a look at Matrix[1], which is basically what you're describing (it's a federated replacement from group chats that has Signal-like E2EE and has an open protocol) and it's already implemented. [1]: https://matrix.org/ https://matrix.org/
- questionasked 7y agoWhat's the advantage of decentralisation? Is it really a problem to have centralised servers if they're just storing dumb encrypted blobs?
- dheera 7y agoGovernments can force the people who own the servers to stop.
- Unklejoe 7y agoCheck out Matrix. Sounds like what you’re describing.
- greyfade 7y agoThere's a lot I'm not explaining, in part because I don't (yet) understand crypto well enough to know if my idea even makes sense, let alone is feasible. Matrix is close, but not what I'm describing. It's far more centralized than I'd like to see.
- lxjm 7y agoXMPP with OTR is exactly this. Facebook messager used to be compatible with XMPP.
- greyfade 7y agoNot exactly. I rather dislike XMPP's design, and what I'd like to see is something not only decentralized (relying at most on a DHT seed), but supporting group chats with trivially-expirable keys. My limited exposure to OTR suggests it only reliably supports one-on-one exchanges.
- nearbuy 7y agoIt should be easier to detect if they're reading it at the ends because they'd then have to retransmit the data to Facebook with a different key.
- lxjm 7y agoI tried to read data transmitted between the facebook messenger app (on iOS) and facebook server but it's encrypted and if you set up a mitm proxy it refuses to transmit. Even if you trust the mitm proxy certificate in the OS settings.
- kd3 7y agoOpen source doesn't guarantee that the compiled source running on your device is the same as what you can view on, for example, GitHub. That is also a trust problem.
- sjy 7y agoIt is much easier to trust that `apt-get install pidgin` will run the published Pidgin source code, than it is to trust that Messenger or WhatsApp will only do the (undocumented) things that I expect them to do.