2 ms·
> So many questions. How did "sexual assault" sneak in here next to homicide? That's not a capital crime. Regardless of one's belief of how murder should be pu
by gumby 7y ago
> So many questions. How did "sexual assault" sneak in here next to homicide? That's not a capital crime.
Regardless of one's belief of how murder should be punished, I think it's pretty clear that rape is an offense as destructive as murder. The reason it does not bear the same penalty is pragmatic: if the punishment were the same then why should a rapist not kill the victim as well? The penalty would be no worse and the chance of being captured would go down.
> How can you give informed consent to sharing your data when the entire point of these sites is not knowing what you discover?
Your question isn't just genetic question but really a mass surveillance question. E.g. relatives tend to look alike so an advanced facial recognition system could be used to, say, see where a wanted suspect's possible relatives live and then follow them in case said suspect contacts them. Or simply look for people who have a "guilt factor" above X near where a crime was committed and sweep them up.
- zeveb 7y ago> The reason it does not bear the same penalty is pragmatic: if the punishment were the same then why should a rapist not kill the victim as well? The real reason is even more prosaic in the U.S.: the Supreme Court in Coker v. Georgia decided that it was unconstitutional, despite having been constitutional and practiced by some number of states for nearly 200 years. It doesn't get any more philosophical than that: six men didn't like it, so the nation doesn't have it any more. But, to the grandparent's point, rape has been a capital crime in the past, and there's no reason it couldn't be again.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]