The letter from Emerald says this: > There are two main causes of concern for Emerald. [...] > Secondly, there are many instances in the manuscript where the

The letter from Emerald says this: > There are two main causes of concern for Emerald. [...] > Secondly, there are many instances in the manuscript where the actions, conversations and behavior of identifiable individuals at specific named colleges are discussed in detail and at length in relation to controversial events. Given the sensitivity of the issues involved, there is both the potential for serious harm to Emerald’s reputation and the significant possibility of legal action. Substantial changes to the content and nature of the manuscript would need to be made, or Emerald would need to accept a high level of risk both reputational and legal. The practical costs and difficulty of managing any reputational or legal problems that did arise are of further concern to Emerald. This is talking about the risk of defamation.