2 ms·
It's kind of futile to give an example of sanctions working to someone who clearly stated that they some times work.
by BeetleB 7y ago
It's kind of futile to give an example of sanctions working to someone who clearly stated that they some times work.
- munk-a 7y agoThat's quite accurate - instead of trying to state any reasoning that would be refutable your statement above doesn't guarantee anything while implying a lot - thus it's pretty unassailable by logic. The implication is rested on a very relaxed statement and will continue to imply even while counter examples are raised.
- BeetleB 7y agoActually, I made a very refutable statement: > Successful sanctions are the exception. To refute, you just need to look at all sanctions, and enumerate the successful ones, and show the proportion is at least half.[0] If "all" sanctions is onerous, a decent sample (e.g. "sanctions in the last 30 years") would still have weight. But simply giving an example of something that the claimant clearly agrees with - that's not even close to a refutation. [0] Clearly one can disagree on what success means, but then nothing in society can yield to logic