3 ms·
Their failings don't remove their achievements. In the case of Gandhi it's not just the current criteria. Even during his time people saw him as a shitty perso
by nabla9 7y ago
Their failings don't remove their achievements.
In the case of Gandhi it's not just the current criteria. Even during his time people saw him as a shitty person. It's good that we stop worshiping great men.
Rabindranath Tagore saw him as a nihilist with fierce joy of annihilation. Many Dalits (untouchables) saw Gandhi as the enemy. While he worked alongside them in some aspects, he was patronizing towards them. Ambedkar said that Gandhi did not deserve to be called mahatma.
Gandhi was monster towards his family. He denied education for his family and tried to force his sons to celibacy. He was against giving his wife penicillin to safe her life for religious reasons and she died. When he himself became a sick soon after, taking quinine was suddenly OK.
Gandhi was a fanatical opponent of sex for pleasure. But just because he didn't do intercourse didn't mean he was not sexually active. For all his celibacy, he had a harem of teenage girls who fought hysterically for the opportunity to sleep naked with him and hold him. Those same girls also gave him his daily enema. He was in today's terminology into 'assplay' and practiced erotic sexual denial with underage girls.
- fouc 7y agocitation needed
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoWell you could read up on Ambdekar, or on Gandhi's hunger strike against untouchable representation. Or his documented letters promoting segregation, also between Indians and Africans. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B._R._Ambedkar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B._R._Ambedkar
- Roritharr 7y agoThis is one of the TILs that I could gladly have skipped. I mean, sometimes you'd rather have a wrong, but more peaceful picture of the world, than live with the impression that literally everyone out has a very dark side to them...
- fyfy18 7y agoSad but true. Enough internet for today I think...
- nabla9 7y agoIgnorance is bliss. If you want to be an adult, you must take the red pill. You can't weigh person by subtracting the negative from positive. Gandhi was still a great man despite his failings.
- beerandt 7y agoNot specific to Gandhi, but I prefer to accept the fact that bad people can accomplish good things worth remembering. And that's OK. And equally, good people can be vilified for choosing the best of two bad options. Also, we put too much blind faith in historians.
- AwfulCaptain 7y agoAccording to your statement, then is Trump a bad person that can accomplish good things?
- hudibras 7y agoLuckily, none of it is true. Or at least a gross exaggeration. As one example, yes, many untouchables didn't support him (there were 300 million people living in India then), but many more did.
- hudibras 7y ago>He was against giving his wife penicillin to safe her life for religious reasons and she died. This is one of those debunked smears that instantly disqualifies whatever else the speaker says. We're talking Elders-of-Zion level smear. (This is where somebody will post as a source the Commentary article from 1983, where the author hears this from somebody at a cocktail party who heard it from someone else.)