3 ms·
Free speech is completely unrelated to deplatforming, regardless whether you believe that’s happening or not. Only the government is required to permit free spe
by arcticbull 7y ago
Free speech is completely unrelated to deplatforming, regardless whether you believe that’s happening or not. Only the government is required to permit free speech, Twitter isn’t, YouTube isn’t, and neither is Fox or Breitbart. Private companies do not have any responsibility to permit speech they disagree with.
No “left winger” (America doesn’t have a left, it has a center right and a far right) has proposed amending the constitution to eliminate free speech. At best they're hoping to move the Overton window.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoIndeed, which is why Youtube is totally within their right to demonetize LGBTQ+ content (any content really, regardless of subject) if it's not acceptable to their advertisers. If you're comfortable with platforms deplatforming what you don't agree with, be prepared to become comfortable with them deplatforming whatever they want, whenever they want.
- arcticbull 7y agoI am. I don’t go to breitbart because I don’t agree with them. If YouTube started doing things I didn’t agree with I’d mosey on too. That’s not entirely true because I still watch an awful lot of Fox but the spirit remains. They don’t tell me what to say and I don’t tell them what to say.
- throwawaysea 7y agoDo you really think it is appropriate for Visa or Mastercard to decline to process payments for Wikileaks? Or for Youtube to demonetize Conservative voices? These platforms control way too much of today's commerce and speech to be treated as just private corporations exercising their rights. That is a disingenuous disregard for the principle of free speech, which is again, more fundamental than the notion of free speech enshrined in current American law.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- arcticbull 7y agoDo I want them to do those things? No, definitely not. Do I think there's a basis for my forcing my views on them? Also no. I think it's difficult because you're looking at a change from the status quo. I'd suggest looking at it from a young upstart business perspective. If a new payment processor wants to start up that doesn't cater to the right -- or to the left -- should that be illegal? Probably not. Is it likely to happen and become successful? No, it's a terrible business decision.
- spangry 7y agoI'm curious, how far does your belief in freedom of association extend? Should a business be allowed to refuse service to someone because they are black, for example? Does your answer change depending of whether that business has many competitors (e.g. a cake shop) or is a near-total monopoly (e.g. google)?
- arcticbull 7y agoOof, that's a tough one. > Should a business be allowed to refuse service to someone because they are black, for example? Is it distasteful? Yeah. Is it a good business model? Nope. Should they be forced to do something they don't want to do? It's hard to say. Discriminatory behavior shouldn't happen, and where it creates material harm (employment, for instance) recourse must exist. Otherwise, I don't know, where no harm occurs it's difficult to justify forcing action. > Does your answer change depending of whether that business has many competitors (e.g. a cake shop) or is a near-total monopoly (e.g. google)? I'd suggest when something becomes essential and doesn't have competition then it becomes "de facto infrastructure" and open access rules are justified. I'm trying to come to a conclusion myself here. Thanks for making me think this through!
- throwawaysea 7y agoNo, free speech is fundamental principle that is not tied to the government. You are conflating free speech and the first amendment as it exists in the US. Private companies that control as much of information exchange as modern tech companies do are serving as a digital public square. They should not have the authority to censor legal speech. Also, America definitely has a far left. Claiming that the most-left cohort of America is center-right is completely disconnected from reality.
- arcticbull 7y ago> No, free speech is fundamental principle that is not tied to the government. You are conflating free speech and the first amendment as it exists in the US. Private companies that control as much of information exchange as modern tech companies do are serving as a digital public square. They should not have the authority to censor legal speech. No, it's not. Free speech is what is enshrined within the First Amendment. Anything beyond that is offered by companies because they hope to make money. You can't compel YouTube to speak any more than you can compel them to stop speaking, to offer you a platform or to take one away. That's not what is guaranteed you as an American. You never had the right to publish anything you want in the newspaper and that hasn’t changed with Twitter. > Also, America definitely has a far left. Claiming that the most-left cohort of America is center-right is completely disconnected from reality. Not in mainstream politics. Democrats are centrist/center-right by world standards. Certainly by European and Canadian standards anyways -- the bulk of the world's other democracies. Find my a single other "far left" politician not 100% committed to socialized medicine, anywhere on earth.
- throwawaysea 7y ago> Free speech is what is enshrined within the First Amendment. Again, the concept of free speech is older than America and more fundamental than the first amendment. What is legal is not the bar. I am not sure I can make it any more clear than that, and I am not sure why you are clinging to current legal definitions when the point I am making is about doing better than the status quo. > Democrats are centrist/center-right by world standards. Certainly by European and Canadian standards anyways -- the bulk of the world's other democracies. As for your claim that Democrats are center-right by "world standards". The world's largest Democracy is India and Democrats would absolutely not be center-right there. Nor in most of Europe. You are likely taking a thin slice of select European countries like Sweden - who themselves are confused at the claims made by the American left about Swedish politics - and casting that as the barometer for what is left, center, or right. Pick whatever semantic label you feel comfortable with. I am talking about the Progressive Left, which is described here as "Progressive Activists": https://hiddentribes.us/profiles https://hiddentribes.us/profiles
- throwaway65436 7y agoFree speech is completely unrelated to deplatforming only if you ascribe to the purely legal definition of it. Many others consider free speech to be much more than a legal concept; it's an ideal that is worthwhile as much in private contexts as it is in public.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- vinay427 7y ago> No “left winger” (America doesn’t have a left, it has a center right and a far right) If we separate this into social and fiscal dimensions or authoritarian and economic dimensions (e.g. the Political Compass), the US certainly does have a major party that's left in some key ways. Assuming at least a few other western countries also have a left by this standard.
- michannne 7y ago>(America doesn’t have a left, it has a center right and a far right) Antifa is center-right? UBI is center-right? Civil rights are center-right? Disregarding that, the rest of your post clearly shows you have a very skewed understanding of how politics (and laws) work.
- arcticbull 7y ago> Antifa is center-right? Frankly I don't know what their specific positions are, but being anti-fascist on the face of it doesn't make you left, it makes you "not far-right." > UBI is center-right? UBI in my mind is apolitical, as it is the inevitable consequence of development. The more we develop, the fewer humans we'll need, as robots will replace them in the work they do. We won't need as many people working as we will have. Luckily as we develop birth rate goes down, so UBI is, for me, an artifact of a transient state where population will shrink to make up for development, and this is a humane way to handle the people who we don't need in the work-force. The alternative is to create jobs we don't need and turn ourselves into a renaissance faire as a make-work project. > Civil rights are center-right? Civil rights should be apolitical. Everyone should believe in civil rights, left or right. Unless "left" means to treat people with respect, and "right" means not doing so, in which case I think you're making my argument, as most political systems treat civil rights as table stakes. > Disregarding that, the rest of your post clearly shows you have a very skewed understanding of how politics (and laws) work. Please do explain where, by law, anyone is required to publish someone else' views verbatim.
- michannne 7y ago>Frankly I don't know what their specific positions are So you clearly don't fully grasp the political climate in the US, but you feel you're somehow qualified to dictate America doesn't have a left? >UBI in my mind is apolitical, as it is the inevitable consequence of development Communism is not "inevitable" >Civil rights should be apolitical. Everyone should believe in civil rights, left or right No, civil rights are a left position, in actuality, a democratic republic such as the US should have some mix of both left and right policy to function freely, it is not the other way around. >Please do explain where, by law, anyone is required to publish someone else' views verbatim. No, because I never stated that they were.