5 ms·
> security versus freedom With the app store you're still vulnerable to state actors and zero day vulns. And on Android you're vulnerable to permissions scope
by echelon 7y ago
> security versus freedom
With the app store you're still vulnerable to state actors and zero day vulns. And on Android you're vulnerable to permissions scope creep. The app stores contain malware.
You're never truly safe.
You can't point to the old days of Windows in the 90s and early 2000s as a case for app stores, either. Installers and downloaded executables were great, but Windows had a broken, unsandboxed model that made it easy to break. History would have played out much better if Windows itself weren't so permissible and was more hermetic back then.
If we invested the same billions of research and development dollars that Apple and Google did into their walled garden platforms, an open web with truly cross platform native wasm apps would work just as well or better than anything on the app stores, and it'd be just as "secure". And cross platform. And couldn't be shut down by Apple, Google, or an angry government.
Imagine going to Netflix.com and getting the native app experience. On any mobile device. Windows Phone. Ubuntu Phone. That's how it should have worked.
Walled gardens must die.
- pjmlp 7y agoI guess that is why everyone just uses Chrome nowadays. /s
- echelon 7y agoGoogle searches used to present Chrome as an app you should download. Google leveraged its market dominance to get people to download their desktop browser. And on Android it's the default you can't uninstall.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Razengan 7y ago> Walled gardens must die. No. As a user, I am grateful for "walled gardens" like the App Store, Steam, etc. Because I remember the chaos that was before them, with developers/publishers preying on users all the time, which they still try to do by working around App Store restrictions and so on. I'm grateful for curated marketplaces putting the foot down on them.
- icelancer 7y ago>> As a user, I am grateful for "walled gardens" like the App Store, Steam, etc. That's nice that you get to experience that. I think the protesters may have a different opinion than you.
- kzzzznot 7y agoWhat are you referring to when you say “scummy developers preying on users”? Honestly asking.
- Razengan 7y agoIf you check the news at any frequency it's hard to miss all the reports of this and that software overextending or abusing its privileges to intrude into the user's computer and privacy. See all the recent news about Chrome, Dropbox, Zoom etc. installing malware on our systems. Steam wiping your disk on Linux when you uninstalled a game. Uber recording your screen. And those are the big players, caught because they're under constant scrutiny (but still try to act as if they're above the "law"). Life before the "walled gardens" was rife with cases like that, from developers on all scales. There was no single authority for your platform to complain to. It was chaotic and miserable even for techie people. This is actually what Apple capitalized on during the "I'm a PC, I'm a Mac" days, and it gave them the credibility to carry on to the App Store. Now I see mostly developers complaining about the walled garden, which makes me wary of their true intentions.
- immigrantsheep 7y agoI'm sorry, I don't understand the point you're trying to make here. You say it's better now that we have walled gardens but then you make a list of all the players that are circumnavigating these anyway. This to me sounds like the worse of both worlds. Some people are still doing whatever they want and at the same time we're prevented to install software from different sources. I agree that at some level it prevents everyone to do it, meaning you have to have at least some basic knowledge to do that but that doesn't seem much from a freedom/security standpoint. For the most part and for most users, those walled gardens are nice but I still think users should have the option to install whatever they want. Put on seven disclaimers about it, but let me do it since, well, I paid for that device.