3 ms·
> That's my dispute. We know X will kill you in a certain time frame. We have thousands if not millions of data points. I fail to see how the control group is r
by jrochkind1 7y ago
> That's my dispute. We know X will kill you in a certain time frame. We have thousands if not millions of data points. I fail to see how the control group is really telling you anything you do not already know.
I don't think you understand the purpose of the control group.
It is irrelevant how much we already know about what Alzheimer's disease does, because the control group is not intended to tell you anything about that at all. The justification for the control group is not that it will tell us something about what Alzheimer's does.
The purpose of the control group is to determine if the treatment works. That's it.
You seem to be suggesting that when doing a research study of a new treatment, it would be unethical not to give this treatment to everyone on the planet who has the disease. That makes no sense at all. The experimental treatment may do nothing for them, or may actually harm them. Giving an experimental unproven treatment to everyone would be unethical.
If you want to argue that it is unnecessary to have control groups in an experiment, you need to first understand what the purpose they are said to serve by those who believe they are important (which is pretty much any statisticians or methodologists).