5 ms·
Actually they aren't doing so great. Everything has changed. Before last year it was basically just Tesla and a few token cars e.g. Leaf in the electric vehicl
by threeseed 7y ago
Actually they aren't doing so great. Everything has changed.
Before last year it was basically just Tesla and a few token cars e.g. Leaf in the electric vehicle space. Now every car company is jumping in and any detractors e.g. BMW CEO are being swiftly moved on.
And so Tesla is now competing against the most highly capitalised, profitable and experienced companies in the world. Porsche Taycan is based on every review the best EV car money can buy. VW has the ID.3/ID.4 coming out shortly which look seriously good and they have plans for 70 models to be released in the coming decade. You have startups like Rivian which are attracting significant outside funding and disrupting segments. And at the cheaper price points you have dozens of Chinese manufacturers entering the fray.
Tesla is about to have the fight of their life and all while they are losing hundreds of millions each quarter.
- llsf 7y agoBut is the size of the market growing even faster ? Tesla is making money on each car sold. But you are right, they do invest a lot in R&D and factory expansion (e.g. new factory in China starting this month to produce model 3 cars). I am still not sure if we can tell now if they are doomed, it might be too early. It is a tricky game, but as long as they make money on each car sold, and keep some technological edge (battery, manufacturing, etc.) they should be fine.
- et2o 7y agoPeople have been making that exact argument for years. There have been so many "Tesla killers" that I've lost count. None have panned out. The Taycan is roughly twice as expensive as the equivalent Model S Tesla and has greatly inferior range and, among people likely to buy electric cars, presumably less brand value. People haven't forgotten VW's emissions scandal. Let's not forget they haven't even shipped a single Taycan yet. BMW has sold a crappy, overpriced electric car/washing-machine-lookalike for years (i3) without it catching on. Furthermore, there's no real competition on the horizon just yet for the Model 3. Tesla have a 3-6 year head start on making electric cars which will be difficult to overcome.
- threeseed 7y agoAnd you seemed to have completely missed my point. Car companies have been doing nothing for years. But now for the first time they are all 100% committed to EV. And as we've seen with the Taycan, EQC and the ID.3/4 they can easily compete with Tesla.
- et2o 7y agoThat remains to be seen. There's no evidence yet. As I already said, people have been making that exact argument for years.
- caconym_ 7y ago> as we've seen with the Taycan and the ID.3/4 they can easily compete with Tesla. The Taycan is not really competing with anything but Tesla's highest-end and presumably lowest-volume products, and the ID.3 and 4 don't exist as production cars yet (AFAIK). Competing with them is obviously possible but these aren't very good examples.
- jm4 7y agoThe Taycan is DOA. If I want an electric car then I’m getting a Tesla because it’s the easiest to own, easiest to charge, the most proven and outperforms every other EV. If I want a Porsche then I’m getting a 911 turbo because it’s their most iconic car. I’m not about to spend 150k on their first attempt at an EV, the riskiest model in their catalog and the one that will most likely sell the lowest volume. I don’t understand where the market is for the Taycan. Forget about it being a “Tesla killer”. It’s good that they’re going electric. I hope they stick with it and do well. But Tesla has already established themselves as a premium brand. It’s not like Porsche is coming in and filling a void here. They are going up against the leader in the leader’s strongest segment, and one which is low volume and not much pie to share.
- clouddrover 7y ago> The Taycan is DOA. No, they'll be selling about 20,000 a year which is what they always planned for. They're actually increasing production capacity at the moment: https://electrek.co/2019/10/02/porsche-taycan-increase-production-high-demand/ https://electrek.co/2019/10/02/porsche-taycan-increase-produ... > I’m not about to spend 150k There are two cheaper variants on the way. Buy one of them if you want: https://www.cnet.com/roadshow/news/cheaper-porsche-taycan-ev/ https://www.cnet.com/roadshow/news/cheaper-porsche-taycan-ev...
- caconym_ 7y agoSo they have competition now, and they're spending more than they're making. What are they spending it on? Maybe they're spending it on the same aggressive growth without which they'd never have achieved the head start they have now? I'm not a Tesla owner nor a Tesla fanboy and my original comment was meant to be a bit tongue-in-cheek, but I have to say that your comment seems to me to be dripping with narrative. Anyway, we will see, won't we? I've got my popcorn ready.
- cjhopman 7y ago> Maybe they're spending it on the same aggressive growth They have cut back drastically on capital expenditures.
- Jakawao 7y agoI do believe that all competitive advantage is temporary and that better offerings are to come from a variety of players... However, there is simply nothing close to Tesla on the planet today. It will be some time before others can catch up. They will. It is inevitable. Right now, Tesla has something others are unable to produce.
- pcurve 7y agoIt really irks me that comments like this are downvoted, including my comment on Tesla. Presumably it's from people who drive Tesla. Come on guys.
- moneytide1 7y agoI translate "losing hundreds of millions each quarter" to "using hundreds of their millions to get entrenched for the approaching Market Share Wars".