3 ms·
Demand mix is a huge problem though. Model 3 is cannibalising sales of the S and X models. Which means their ARPU and gross margin has rapidly decreased causin
by threeseed 7y ago
Demand mix is a huge problem though.
Model 3 is cannibalising sales of the S and X models. Which means their ARPU and gross margin has rapidly decreased causing impacts to their revenue and profit.
Tesla's fiscal position is simply unsustainable.
- clomond 7y agoI'm sorry for being pedantic here - but your final sentence does not necessarily follow from the previous. Lowering ARPUs and tightening gross margin % are an issue - yes. But the single most important factor here is gross margin in absolute terms. If sales volume increases to offset decreasing ARPUs, this doesn't make 'Tesla's fiscal position simply unsustainable'.
- threeseed 7y agoSales volumes are not offsetting decreasing ARPUs though. That's the problem. And you only have to look at Tesla's profit numbers to see this.
- ccorda 7y agoLast 4 quarters of free cash flow, seems quite sustainable: June 30, 2019 590.40M March 31, 2019 -944.80M Dec. 31, 2018 880.66M Sept. 30, 2018 831.52M
- threeseed 7y agoThis is what you want to be looking at: https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/TSLA/tesla/net-income https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/TSLA/tesla/net-inc...
- llsf 7y agoLooking at it, it is revenue, gross profit and net income are all increasing by double digit percentage, every year. Still Tesla is spending a lot more, but less every year compare to the revenue. They are expanding quite quickly (new factory in China starting to produce this month), maybe too quickly ? It would be interesting to see during the next 6 months, how the production in China affects Tesla results.
- dragontamer 7y agoAsk yourself: how much does a $5 Billion factory affect net-income. Answer: a $5 Billion factory costs $0 in terms of profit. Its a capital-expenditure, affecting Cash Flow (not profits). Depreciation is how factories "wear out" in the income statement. Tesla is not selling enough cars to make up for its $5 Billion investment in the Gigafactory. After many years, Tesla will only have made ~$4 Billion from a $5 Billion factory, by the time it has to replace all the equipment and pay $5 Billion again. (Made up numbers to roughly estimate what is going on here). Tesla needs to make more cars out of the factory it has already built if they want to be able to rebuild the factory by the time all the parts wear out.
- llsf 7y agoThe Chinese Gigafactory cost $5B and should eventually produce 500,000 cars (less than 10,000 a week like its counterpart in US). If it takes 5 years to wear out, then Tesla would have to make ~$2k per car produced to pay the factory. I am curious to see how this Chinese factory would perform in the next 6 months. Clearly the plan has been to produce more per factory, and it did not happen yet. But I have faith in automation to eventually improve the factory's output.
- dragontamer 7y ago> But I have faith in automation to eventually improve the factory's output. Tesla's CapEx has been disappointingly low. Any kind of improved automation will require new equipment. Unless Tesla can scrape together more cash to improve their CapEx figures, its basically impossible for them to get "Better equipment". IMO, Musk is spending too much money on unnecessary projects (ex: Cuphead ported to Tesla. Full-self driving custom designed chip. Etc. etc.) and not enough money on simple & boring stuff like better factory equipment.
- llsf 7y agoYes, I agree Tesla might have spent money on non essential (more video games), or at least non-trivial return (self driving custom designed chip). But Tesla did acquire Grohmann (automation), which is kind of boring stuff like better factory equipment. On a side note, I have been bullish on automation for a couple years, and it did not pan out, both Fanuc and KUKA had a rough past year... so no revolution on the automation/robot so far.
- agumonkey 7y agoHonestly, unless they're doing really stupid things, they were announced dead every month during the previous years. Incapable of scaling etc etc.. Now they do. I think they'll do fine. (unless they do stupid things)
- grizzles 7y agoS and X models are just the model 3 chassis with a different body & trim. Those are the parts of the car that are easy to change. Effectively they are selling the same product at 3 different price points. That's retail 101.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 7y ago>S and X models are just the model 3 chassis with a different body & trim. That's incorrect.
- grizzles 7y agoWell let's see. They use the same range of Tesla batteries. They use the same motors. The same brakes (Brembo), same transmission, similar suspension. Neither have an ic engine, fuel tank or radiator. The difference in the wheelbase between the Model X (116.7) and Model (116.5) is 0.2 inches. As I said a different body. If I'm incorrect tell me how.
- davidgould 7y agoWell, none of it is correct. S and X are mostly aluminum, Model 3 is mostly steel. S and X use AC induction motors, Model 3 uses PM motor (yeah, Raven and all, but historically this is true). S and X use 18650 cells, Model 3 uses 21700 cells with a different cooling architecture. Your definition of "the same" covers almost every electric made, not just Tesla. It's a stretch too far.
- nickik 7y agoWhy are you just straight up lying about things that can be checked with ease?
- grizzles 7y agoI said the body was different. Tesla standardizing on Raven is not really a counterexample. These other differences (eg. a few extra battery cells) are so chickenshit that if a factory level product engineer was making these changes 99% of the time it would be signed off by max one other engineer. I know because I used to be one of those engineers. The gist of what I'm saying is totally true. It's not like they are using different battery chemistries on their different models. All their big stuff has moved or is moving to a common platform.
- woodandsteel 7y agoAt the end of the previous quarter Tesla had 4 billion in the bank, its highest ever. It also has a new factory in China that is about to go into production, and several new models that will be coming out. And its efficiencies of production keep improving. People like you have been predicting every quarter for the last 10 years that Tesla was on the verge of going out of business, and yet it keeps going from one success to another.