3 ms·
You do realize that the Islamic prohibition on interest comes directly from the Christian New Testament, right? That early Christians forbade interest for centu
by WorldMaker 7y ago
You do realize that the Islamic prohibition on interest comes directly from the Christian New Testament, right? That early Christians forbade interest for centuries? That some Christian groups still forbid collecting interest?
- Thiez 7y agoIt is no coincidence that many jews used to be in the money lending business in those times. They could not charge interest on loans made to other jews, but christians (and other non-jews) were fair game. Sadly this did not improve their popularity...
- lazyasciiart 7y agoLots of other reasons too, like fears of being driven out of town and having to abandon any physical goods and stores, not being allowed to own land (so no farmers), not being allowed to join many craft guilds....
- gowld 7y agoAlso, Christians were banned from lending, but didn't ban lending, so they needed non-Christians to fill the need.
- faissaloo 7y agoJews also forbid interest among themselves.
- WillPostForFood 7y agoSo maybe the quote should be: "Every truly long-lived civilization gives up on banning interest"
- reissbaker 7y agoAs other posters have mentioned, but to put a little more emphasis on how this worked: the Christian world of early to middle Europe banned Christians collecting interest on loans (which, effectively, banned Christians from operating loan-based financial service businesses). They didn't ban interest on loans in general, and in fact depended on loans with interest. They outsourced their financial services to their minority Jewish populations, and then every hundred years or so when the interest payments piled up too high, they evicted and/or massacred all their Jews, and seized their property. Not a great deal for the Jews! Although they were also legally barred from doing almost any other work (they could also be tax-collectors, which was hardly a better job)[1]. But it's definitely not the case that the civilizations of Christian Europe didn't have loans with interest. This was also largely true in Islamic societies: they did rely on loans with interest, by once again relying on their minority Jewish population to provide financial services. [2] Unlike the Christians, though, the Muslims generally paid back their loans instead of murdering their creditors. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medieval_antisemitism#Restrictions_to_marginal_occupations_(tax_collecting,_moneylending,_etc.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medieval_antisemitism#Restrict... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riba#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riba#History
- rossdavidh 7y agoTrue, but "ok we will have interest but periodically massacre the people interest is owed to", is much like not having interest, except nastier. You are, in a sense, avoiding the problem of an interest load spiraling up out of control. But, it's true, it was not a perfect ban, but it certainly did have the practical impact of not allowing those to whom interest is owed, from hijacking control of the state. Again, not in a good way, but I think it shows that long-lived civilizations eventually find that the Mathew Effect is particularly strong with interest, and must be reined in somehow. Hopefully in a better way than the medieval Christian one.
- reissbaker 7y agoOr, alternatively, you could notice how the Islamic states managed to do exactly the same thing but without massacres.
- hangonhn 7y agoIt's actually much, much more devious than that in the Christian world. In England, Jews aren't consider the subject of the local lords. They're subjects of the king directly so they paid their taxes to him directly. Thus by raising taxes on the Jews, the kings of Englands were able to indirectly tax his nobles (because the cost would be passed on to their creditors) while throwing the Jews under the bus. This is why you see at various times in English history that the nobles call for the eviction of the Jews.
- hangonhn 7y agoIt's actually more nuanced than that. Interest isn't banned outright. Interests on things that carried risk was fine so interest on foreign exchange was fine. This was how the banking families of Italy like the Medici made so much money. The ban on usury is only on non-secured loans or loans secured by the person. For example, mortgage is actually OK because the debtor can default and walk away. However, loans that are secured by the person who must pay cannot collect interest. This, IIRC, comes from St. Thomas Aquinas.
- lordgrenville 7y agoMinor point: the prohibition actually goes back to the Old Testament (Leviticus 25:36), whereas the New Testament seems strangely OK with it (in the parable of the talents [1]). Also Leviticus explicitly permits you to charge interest to an outsider, which is why Christians outsourced it to Jews. [1] http://www.yourfaithyourfinance.org/money-and-faith/usury-and-the-theology-of-money/usury-in-the-new-testament/ http://www.yourfaithyourfinance.org/money-and-faith/usury-an...
- WorldMaker 7y agoRight, I forgot it was Leviticus with the most clear passage on the subject. Though, I suppose I've heard more of the anti-usury interpretation of the Parable of Talents than the straight reading. I also know that the Parable of the Moneylender is brought up sometimes as anti-usury by the way it conflates usury with sin directly in its analogy. Also, the tale of kicking the moneylenders out of the temple is often mentioned alongside these examples.
- cardiffspaceman 7y agoYou might find that the tale is about money changers who changed various things into shekels so that the client could then pay the temple tax [1]. I don't think that line of business is connected with usury, unless you look at making a market in an item using a bid-ask spread as selling a cake and charging separately for its consumption [2]. [1] https://www.bibleodyssey.org/en/passages/main-articles/jesus-and-the-moneychangers https://www.bibleodyssey.org/en/passages/main-articles/jesus... [2] http://www.yourfaithyourfinance.org/money-and-faith/usury-and-the-theology-of-money/thinking-about-usury/ http://www.yourfaithyourfinance.org/money-and-faith/usury-an...