4 ms·
Check the caption for the "Median Annual Wages..." graph: "Teacher salaries are adjusted based on the assumption of a 10-month work year." ...which is a good
by mcguire 7y ago
Check the caption for the "Median Annual Wages..." graph:
"Teacher salaries are adjusted based on the assumption of a 10-month work year."
...which is a good way to give them a virtual 17% pay raise. I wonder if the same applies to other professions like independent contractors or lawyers, who can only charge for part of their working time.
- jschwartzi 7y agoYeah, and this makes so much sense considering how easy it is to find a high-paying 2-month temporary job. /s It's the old "You don't understand, teachers only work 10 months out of the year!" argument but dressed in some nice statistical clothing. It's asinine to make that argument because teachers can't actually get paid for the other two months. When I was temping in a warehouse unloading shipping containers one summer, there were a few teachers there who were just making ends meet until the school year started.
- Mirioron 7y agoOn the other hand, plenty of people working other jobs that would like to have 2 entire months off every year.
- mcguire 7y agoSure. It's one of the biggest advantages of teaching. But you still can't pay for groceries with time off.
- darawk 7y agoYou can't pay for groceries with health insurance either but you still have to include fringe benefits when calculating total compensation.
- XorNot 7y agoWell, in other first-world countries you don't.
- darawk 7y agoI'm not sure what your point is. You have to include fringe benefits generally when calculating total compensation. Whether or not that happens to include healthcare is pretty immaterial.
- Faark 7y agoYes, but the value of benefits is highly dependent on the employee. 30% off international flights might be an awesome deal, but unlikely for someone who cannot even afford a car. Vacation has great value, but usually only after basic needs are met. Cutting someones hours is often used as a punishment for a reason. At the same time it also makes total sense that other companies don't want employees reducing their working hours.
- darawk 7y ago> Yes, but the value of benefits is highly dependent on the employee. 30% off international flights might be an awesome deal, but unlikely for someone who cannot even afford a car. Sure but that's a strange point to make given that they know what the benefits of the job are in advance. It's not like summer vacation is something that's sprung on teachers after they've taken the job. > Vacation has great value, but usually only after basic needs are met. Cutting someones hours is often used as a punishment for a reason. At the same time it also makes total sense that other companies don't want employees reducing their working hours. Most teachers are not incapable of meeting their own basic needs. They may be paid less than comparable private sector workers, but they're not literally starving. Given that, vacation is unequivocally a benefit. They may prefer the opportunity to work more...but if they preferred that, then they should have taken a different job.
- awinder 7y agoYeah came here to talk about the same thing. Teachers have a 40 hour a week in the school job paired with a 10-20 hour wfh job preparing lessons, grading papers, etc. Those summer months are paid for by extra hours during the school year as far as I’m concerned. This is also not even getting into how much teachers spend of their salary money on the classroom. Which is so prevalent that there’s a tax deduction for it. How many masters professions involve spending salary money for the employer?
- humanrebar 7y agoHow many master's professions insist on local monopolies for their employers? Other than predisposed ideological beliefs, it doesn't make sense for teachers' unions to be as against school competition as they are, at least with respect to employing exemplary educators.
- claudeganon 7y agoTeacher’s unions don’t opposes “school competition.” They oppose school privatization, which is largely a predatory scheme with wildly misaligned incentives. We don’t need a repeat of all the problems with the US healthcare system in education. Conflating performance with unions is bunk anyways. Japan’s teachers are heavily, heavily unionized, historically far more militant than teachers in the US, and they’re consistently among the highest performing OECD countries.
- darawk 7y ago> Teacher’s unions don’t opposes “school competition.” They oppose school privatization, How would one have meaningful 'competition' without privatization?
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoThough I doubt it would work very well in practice, students could be free to enroll in school in another school district with their home district paying a tuition fee to the host district.