3 ms·
Why do you feel that "you're welcome" implies an obligation Because my observation/experience is that in American culture, most people operate from a default a
by Mz 16y ago
Why do you feel that "you're welcome" implies an obligation
Because my observation/experience is that in American culture, most people operate from a default assumption of one up/one down and are constantly jockeying for their position in pecking order. I get this type of thing a lot less from other cultures. But quite a lot of Americans seem unable to interact as equals and are constantly trying to force the other person into a one down position in order to avoid being in the one down position themselves. I am painfully aware of this because, frequently, if I refuse to take the one down position and try to interact as equals, they react like I am trying to insult and oppress them and force them into the one down position -- many people seem unable to conceive of some other paradigm. Saying "You are welcome" suggests "I provided you with something of value, thus I am one up on you." -- at least to most people I interact with. I do a lot of things to try to disengage from this process of jockeying for position. I dislike it intensely.
- maxawaytoolong 16y agoWhat is a concrete example of saying "you're welcome" where it leads to the oppression you're describing?
- Mz 16y agoI find that when I tell people "you are welcome" in online forums where I have a reputation as someone who is knowledgeable, it reinforces the idea that 'some folks here know stuff and the rest are losers and are just here to ask questions and beg for help'. I have actively combated that tendency for years in online forums I have belonged to. I have found that "no problem" or "no big" or a similar response fosters more equitable conversation, where more members feel able to be contributing members who know stuff and can give information. Saying "You are welcome" reinforces the idea that what I have shared is "advice" rather than "information" and suggests I have some authority to tell them how to live their lives, which is generally something I do not want. In my experience, it creates a great many problems (edit: including people vociferously attacking me and trying to tear down my supposed "authority", which I never wanted in the first place). Sharing anecdotes, telling my story, sharing information -- this is something any member can do for the benefit of the group as a whole without needing to be "right" or "authoritative" and it undermines the tendency to fight for pecking order which typically goes on.