3 ms·
You'll notice a lot of people commenting here "my wife is a teacher" (myself included). I think these statistics are missing two very big factors. - In high c
by jedberg 7y ago
You'll notice a lot of people commenting here "my wife is a teacher" (myself included). I think these statistics are missing two very big factors.
- In high cost areas like the Silicon Valley, almost every teacher is married to an engineer or is the child of an engineer. That is why they don't need a second job. Because they have a support network.
- Teacher quits are low because most of the people who would be great teachers simply never get into the job because of the crappy pay and work conditions. The people who are the best at it could easily get other jobs. My wife if a great example -- during the summer she worked a temp job in the first few years that was basically a management job that would have an annual salary in the six figure range. She only kept doing teaching because she loved it and because I made enough money to support us.
- Florin_Andrei 7y ago> That is why they don't need a second job. Because they have a support network. If an alien visitor to Earth was looking at this sorry situation, they could make some interesting assumptions about the priorities of this society and culture, as a whole, with regards to education.
- prepend 7y agoThere’s actual data on both points you make. These anecdotes and conjectures are not very valuable. There are high quit rates in other industries that would have the same loss of potentially awesome staff as well. Why do teachers quit so infrequently compared to other professions? Maybe it’s because it is a low risk job with really unusual benefits (2 months fixed leave every summer). Lots of people work for jobs that they love, it’s not unique to teaching. Comically, love of job drives salary down because it increases supply. If teachers hated their job the salaries would go up because it would decrease supply.
- jedberg 7y agoThere is no data on how many people don't choose to teach because of the perception of low wage and poor working conditions. I'm not even sure how you would measure that. I also can't think of another profession that has the same reputation. Most jobs have a reputation of either poor working conditions or low pay, or if they have both, are unskilled or low skilled positions. Teaching is the only job I can think of with low pay, poor conditions, and high skill required (a bachelor's+credential or master's degree).
- usefulcat 7y agoPerhaps teaching jobs tend to be easier to get compared to other "high skill" jobs?
- throwaway_bad 7y ago> I also can't think of another profession that has the same reputation Game development? Much lower pay relative to other programming jobs, insane hours, and usually requires much deeper and specialized skills. I guess it's not low pay on an absolute scale like teaching is.
- jschwartzi 7y ago> - In high cost areas like the Silicon Valley, almost every teacher is married to an engineer or is the child of an engineer. That is why they don't need a second job. Because they have a support network. This reminds me of a girl in one of my teacher education classes(I have a certification that I've never used because software engineering pays way better and was easier to break into back in '09). We were talking about teacher pay and she mentioned that since she was going to have her husband support her she didn't see any reason to campaign for a higher salary, which was pretty inflammatory for just about the entire rest of the class.
- spike021 7y ago>In high cost areas like the Silicon Valley, almost every teacher is married to an engineer or is the child of an engineer. That is why they don't need a second job. Because they have a support network. Huh? My neighbor at my (fortunately extremely low-cost) apartment is single, a teacher, and he barely gets by, especially in summer (if he wants to have "fun money" during summer it means taking a summer school teaching job). Obviously one person out of a plethora of teachers in the Bay Area, but that's a ridiculously general statement.
- jedberg 7y agoI mean my N is about 150 (the number of teachers I know personally regarding their living situation) and all but a few are married to a high earner or are supported by high earning parents. The rest have either been teaching for 30+ years and got lucky enough to buy a house way back then, and one of them is married to a cop and together they make a decent wage because he has a good union. There's only one that I know that is single and without support, and she lived with me because we rented her a room at 1/2 normal rents until she could afford to buy a condo.