3 ms·
Having had a chance to talk to the Libra Foundation folks (where development of the actual underlying technology is going on), they are themselves distancing th
by derefr 7y ago
Having had a chance to talk to the Libra Foundation folks (where development of the actual underlying technology is going on), they are themselves distancing their organization from Facebook in every way possible, and have been since the start.
To them, Libra is an open (to consortium membership) blockchain network, whereas the thing Facebook is bringing to it is just a wallet product (Calibra) for holding and transferring the Libra-native cryptocurrency. They speak of Calibra with not-just-a-little distaste, in the same sense that you might speak of a rich investor in your company that you never really wanted investing in you but were desperate. They don’t really offer any special support for, or primacy to, Calibra; to them, it’s an unseemly app by an unseemly company that’ll happen to boost usage of their network from “some unknown blockchain” to “a blockchain 80% of the world has access to through an app they already have on their phones” (so they can’t exactly just tell it to go fly a kite.)
It’s interesting that, from the perspective of other companies in this consortium (or perhaps just the news media’s interpretation of it), the Libra Foundation “is” Facebook. It’s no more Facebook than, say, WebKit.org “is” Apple, or any ASF Committee “is” one of its sponsoring partners.
In all of those cases, there are employees of the sponsoring company steering the project, sure, but not in their capacity as employees; rather, it’s something they’re doing for the Foundation, not even billed to their employer. (How do features get developed? The employees, as the employer, using billable hours, create and submit PRs “upstream” to the Foundation. Then, the employees, as members of the Foundation, along with other Foundation members, vote on the PRs.)
Importantly, if the sponsoring company decided to withdraw its support from any of the relevant projects, the Foundation would still exist, and those people who are employees and also members of the Foundation would still be members of the Foundation—because they are personally, themselves members, not members as delegates of the sponsoring company.
Importantly as well, the employees who happen to also be members of the Foundation almost always have an understanding with their employer that—because they would be kicked out of the Foundation’s steering committee if they showed any favouritism toward PRs made by their employer—they have to treat their employer’s suggestions just like anyone else’s. With most such projects, if you subscribe to the mailing lists, you wouldn’t be able to tell they had any sponsoring partners at all!
I just want to highlight this, because it seems like nobody really understands this until they work on at least one project run this way. (My own experience is with Apache CouchDB, whose main contributor is IBM Cloudant.)
- throwawaylolx 7y ago>It’s interesting that, from the perspective of other companies in this consortium (or perhaps just the news media’s interpretation of it), the Libra Foundation “is” Facebook. Isn't this how they decided to market themselves? The first news of it had Facebook plastered all over. Even their whitepaper says: >Facebook teams played a key role in the creation of the Libra Association and the Libra Blockchain, working with the other Founding Members. While final decision-making authority rests with the association, Facebook is expected to maintain a leadership role through 2019. Facebook created Calibra, a regulated subsidiary, to ensure separation between social and financial data and to build and operate services on its behalf on top of the Libra network. Stating that "Facebook is expected to maintain a leadership role through 2019" would also lead me to believe that Libra Foundation "is" Facebook for most practical purposes.
- derefr 7y ago“Facebook is expected to maintain a leadership role” in the Consortium, in the sense that—as the news article states—none of the other nominal Founding Member companies are bothering to do any steering of the Foundation. AFAIK Facebook wants to get away from the helm of the Libra Foundation ship and give it over to the rest of the Founding Members ASAP (because that’s better for Libra’s image!), but the Founding Members won’t take Libra seriously until it gains traction (which it won’t until Calibra launches.) Kind of a chicken-and-egg thing.