3 ms·
I'm not arguing TOR is "superior" - rather it just demonstrates a use of not needing to trust an upstream. It's also another datapoint for how easy it is to bol
by mindslight 7y ago
I'm not arguing TOR is "superior" - rather it just demonstrates a use of not needing to trust an upstream. It's also another datapoint for how easy it is to bolt on transport security.
The general principle I'm appealing to is that it's better for a protocol to be missing more-critical qualities that are easier to add later, than less-critical but harder-to-change qualities that will forever be a hindrance. Signed records make for a fundamental security property that cannot be made up for with transport security.
Another way of looking at it is that the records in DNS/DNSSEC form a higher layer protocol than the server-to-server communication. Every party in the system has to agree on the format/semantics of those data objects, whereas the server-to-server protocols can be upgraded pairwise.