8 ms·
The IBM Pentium 4 64-Bit CPU
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mmansoor78 7y agoI really admire all the lengths that the author went for this. Hard to see types of efforts now a days.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- calmworm 7y agoRight. I imagined this as a loose script to a Netflix special.
- walrus01 7y agoThis really isn't anything special, at the time of release it was a low end single socket 1ru server. It overlapped with available 64bit lga775 versions of the same product.
- peter_d_sherman 7y agoExcerpt: "Having such a unique processor at your disposal, it’s absurd not to build a powerful x64-retro system on it. One of the options for using such a system in general can be to build a universal “PC-harvester” that supports all Microsoft operating systems from DOS to Windows 10." All Microsoft OS'es on the same PC? Cool! Also, if that's indeed the case, my guess is that most versions of x86 Linux and other x86 OS'es, historic to present, would work too... which is no small feat for a single PC...
- hapless 7y agoYou may wonder, what was in this for IBM? The answer is fairly straightforward. IBM used to make proprietary chipsets for Intel chips! The pride of the xServer/xSeries systems were "complex" setups -- multiple chassis -- with up to 32 sockets, and 512 GB of RAM. These required a lot of IBM internal engineering, where they made pin-compatible sockets for what Intel was offering at the time, and glued those chips into _hugely_ different topologies than Intel had in mind. These systems sound small today, but back in 2001, this was a really big deal for x86. The IBM-proprietary chipsets were much more expensive than off-the-shelf systems, but still a fair bit cheaper than going with NCR or Unisys, competing vendors with proprietary x86 MP designs. IBM had a lot at stake when that socket changed. Achieving pin-compatibility is hard! Intel is very jealous of their documentation, and prefers to offer paper only, with water-marked copies. It's like owning a gutenberg bible. Engineering something pin-compatible with an Intel x86 CPU has never been easy. It was no doubt worth it to their "big" x86 server business to ask Intel to make a special run of chips with the old socket layout, but the new emt64 extensions. I bet it was a complete no-brainer compared to the costs of integrating a new socket!
- walrus01 7y agoIn the era of dual socket, single core xeons, ServerWorks also produced non Intel chipsets, North and South bridge, for motherboard makers to use. There were tyan and supermicro boards that used them. Common at the time in 1ru and 2ru size servers. Also found on big quad socket supermicro boards. From 2002: https://www.extremetech.com/extreme/73498-serverworks-ships-grand-champion-chipset https://www.extremetech.com/extreme/73498-serverworks-ships-... I actually think the ibm systems used the grandchampion chipset. https://www.supermicro.com/products/motherboard/Xeon/GC-HE/P4QH6.cfm https://www.supermicro.com/products/motherboard/Xeon/GC-HE/P... Serverworks was later acquired by broadcom.
- jumpingmice 7y agoIBM was locked in a brutal fight with HP and Dell to take share in the early x86 server market. Their chipsets were neat but they looked silly next to an HP Opteron box. Integrated memory control ended the chipset race. Still their chipsets had neat features worth remembering, such as the ability to use local main memory as a last-level cache of memory read from remote nodes. And of course they went to 64 sockets which was respectable.
- walrus01 7y agoAs I recall HP also used serverworks for a lot of dual socket 2ru systems, for people who didn't want to buy opteron (and from 2000 to 2003 before the release of opteron)
- hapless 7y agoThese are pretty bold words, my friend. Opteron had vastly better architecture than the Intel chipsets of the day, but it topped out at four or eight sockets, I forget. IBM, at the time, could offer you Opteron-like architecture and performance, with up to 32 sockets, using Intel chips. That was worthwhile to some customers. "Intel" wasn't the selling position. It was x86 or x86-64, with "big" as the selling position. I'm not here to apologize for Intel. I'm just saying, those IBM proprietary chipsets had their nice bits.
- earenndil 7y ago> Having such a unique processor at your disposal, it’s absurd not to build a powerful x64-retro system on it. One of the options for using such a system in general can be to build a universal “PC-harvester” that supports all Microsoft operating systems from DOS to Windows 10. I thought all modern intel/amd cpus are backwards compatible back to the 8086, and so capable of doing that?
- hapless 7y agoYou would need the firmware to also be backwards compatible. It's presumably easier to find a socket 478 motherboard with ISA slots and very old-style firmware.
- whenchamenia 7y agoI had to do this. Needed ISA, and a newer OS. Search for 'industrial motherboard' and it gets way easier, but somewhat more expensive.
- core-questions 7y agoPlease tell me what you ended up with, I have a waferprober that needs some love.
- exikyut 7y agoWhat specifically does it need to interface with? An ISA slot? Non-USB-dongle RS232?
- core-questions 7y agoI need three ISA slots for Weird Proprietary 80s Shit, probably parallel+serial as well
- exikyut 7y ago
- joering2 7y agoWas actually pretty good read. How far are we from 128-bit architecture ?
- jve 7y agoWe're still VERY far away to utilize 6 Exabytes of addressable space 64-bit offers us. If we talk about RAM, CPU architecture limits it to 4PB.
- frabert 7y agoWhat for? AVX512 instructions can work on, well, 512bits of data at a time, while 64bits worth of address lines offer way more ram than available today. What's your use case?
- joering2 7y agoNo particular use case. I think its one of these things when they first built machine then all of sudden bunch of different uses case are found.
- majewsky 7y agoWhy do I need to build a 128-bit machine to imagine a usecase for it? What you refer to is not applicable to usecases, only to business cases. We first had to build broadband internet before video streaming websites became a viable business model, but surely someone thought of video streaming during the dialup era?
- jdsully 7y agoAVX512 is not comparable to 128-bit native. AVX/SSE are split into lanes of maximum 64-bits. You can not compute a 128-bit result only multiple 64 bit ones in parallel.
- frabert 7y agoThat's a microarchitectural detail, point is you can view modern CPUs as more than 64bit wide, at least databus-wise.
- Animats 7y agoWhat's striking is that 3.4GHz 64 bit Intel CPUs were shipping 15 years ago. That's still about where we are, but with more cores per package.
- Tuna-Fish 7y agoThe single core IPC has gone up >3.5 times in that time. So even if the advancement isn't as fast as it was in the gigahertz race times, it's not exactly standing still either. https://cpu.userbenchmark.com/Compare/Intel-Pentium-4-380GHz-vs-Intel-Core-i7-6700K/m11003vs3502 https://cpu.userbenchmark.com/Compare/Intel-Pentium-4-380GHz...
- foepys 7y agoIPC has improved significantly over the last 15 years. You cannot compare the raw clocks.
- jcranmer 7y agoFrequency stalled because we stopped being able to efficiently cool the CPUs at that point. Heat output is proportional to power consumption, which is proportional roughly to the cube of frequency (power is normally proportional to the square of frequency, but to drive higher frequencies, you often need to drive up the voltage--which also has an effect on power).
- aeyes 7y agoThat can't be the only reason, with every shrink power requirements have been reduced. P4 had up to 115W TDP. The same frequency and raw power could probably be achieved on 15W today. But you can't get most current CPUs to run stable beyond 4GHz base clock, even with liquid cooling.
- fivefive55 7y agoNot sure what cpus you're looking at but everything in the desktop space is over 4ghz nowadays. My last cpu was at 4.6ghz its entire life and my 3900x stays at over 4ghz on all 12 cores when doing a render.
- klingonopera 7y agoI was once looking for a used Intel Core2Duo processor on eBay, not sure, I think it was the E6300, 7x266Mhz, great FSB overclocking potential, and then settled on buying a CPU that was advertised as such, but its lid had "Intel Confidential" on it. IDK, did the seller delid and relid it with something exotic? Or did I snag one of the first prototypes? What was up with that lid? Does anyone have a clue? MB identified an E6300, and it had amazing overclocking potential, it went 7x333Mhz without any voltage increase. Not sure what the max was, but considering only a few people were bidding on it (I'm guessing most were turned away due to that lid), I was quite lucky to get a CPU with a lot of potential for very little cash.
- ksaj 7y agoTake a look at the picture in the Intel Slashes Prices article posted here. It has "Intel Confidential" etched on it.
- klingonopera 7y ago> https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21132809 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21132809 Yep, that's exactly it, except it was Core2Duo, IDK, must've been around 2009 or so, when I bought it used.
- planteen 7y agoI've had Intel engineering samples from work (we got them under NDA and such). They were tossing some Sandy Bridge engineering samples at some point and let us take them home. The hardware was buggy and didn't get microcode updates IIRC. The case and mobo was leaf blower loud and very unwieldy. I could run Linux for a few hours before it would segfault. I ended up trashing it. So I don't think an Intel engineering sample is better, I think it is worse.
- klingonopera 7y agoDid those have "Intel Confidential" on them? The CPU I bought was working fine though, the seller guaranteed it and he had the reputation on eBay to back it. My (possibly) naive logic then, was that an early sample was likely to be made from the best silicon, which often correlates with good OC potential...
- icodestuff 7y agoPrescott was 64-bit from the first stepping (C0), but EM64T was disabled with fuses. It wasn't just introduced for E0, and it was disabled in the G steppings that were 32-bit the same way. That big a change is too large to do in a mask change (the letter incrementing in a stepping indicates a mask change, the number a metal change) rather than a microarchitectural one. There are probably engineering samples of C and D steppings floating around out there that don't have those fuses blown. The same is true for the LGA775-based 32-bit Prescotts. 64-bit disabled by fuses.