4 ms·
"Race-Conscious Admissions" obviously implies that a candidates race influences the criteria they must meet for admission to the university. So Harvard is obvi
by CivBase 7y ago
"Race-Conscious Admissions" obviously implies that a candidates race influences the criteria they must meet for admission to the university. So Harvard is obviously trying to balance the racial demographics of their students according to some ratio.
What I really want to know is what ratio they are balancing towards and why that particular ratio is better than any other.
I could pick any arbitrary ratio. How about a ratio that matches the modern demographics of Cambridge? Or Massachusetts? Or the United States? Or North America? Or all of Earth? Or the demographics of the US in 1636 when Harvard was established? Or the demographics some designer thinks looks good in pictures? Or the demographics of the wealthiest 5% of US citizens? Or the demographics of the poorest 5%? So on and so on.
What is the incentive? Is it political? Is it just a ratio that Harvard admins think will keep them safe from political criticism? That clearly didn't work. Are they getting a kickback somehow? Is it a personal agenda to promote education in places the admins agree lacks it? Is it simple bigotry?
I doubt the answers would change my mind, but I'm still very interested.
- FakeComments 7y agoEvery group but whites and Hispanics are over represented at Harvard. Whites are the most under represented group. Whatever their goal, it’s not matching the demographics of the US and constitutes purposeful racism to accomplish a social agenda. See other comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21130080 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21130080