4 ms·
> I had perfect test scores and grades If Harvard wanted to admit 1,000 kids with perfect test scores and perfect grades they’d just take the first 1,000 appli
by paulcole 7y ago
> I had perfect test scores and grades
If Harvard wanted to admit 1,000 kids with perfect test scores and perfect grades they’d just take the first 1,000 applicants and call it a day.
They can be and are much choosier than that. Why wouldn’t they be? If you have the choice between a 4.0/1600 kid and a 4.0/1600/world-class pianist, who would you take?
When applying to Harvard grades and test scores aren’t even worth mentioning. If you’re counting on those to get you in then you’ve got almost no shot.
- opportune 7y agoSure, but there are at least 4 other colleges that are about as prestigious and selective as Harvard for STEM. Back in my day I think it was something like 1000 kids a year got perfect scores between the two standardized tests, and the class sizes at all of these places is about 1600 (except Caltech which was like 250). I agree it is about more than grades and test scores, and I did have other stuff too, but that's beside the point. Arguing about that is missing the point of what I intended - what I meant is that if you are one of the better applicants, which I do think I was quantitatively (obviously not good enough lol), you don't need to go to Harvard. Whereas for some of the people getting in who might not have without affirmative action, getting into Harvard is actually life changing.
- jessriedel 7y agoSort of. They certainly could take a class that had only perfect scores, and they also certainly select based on other criteria, but selecting on these other criteria seriously impact the typical scores of admits. I think Caltech students do noticeably better on every quantitative metric, both in terms of means and medians.
- bsder 7y ago> If you have the choice between a 4.0/1600 kid and a 4.0/1600/world-class pianist, who would you take? Which would be fine. Unfortunately, they take the 3.4/1420/Tennis Player instead. All of these schools have been proven over and over to reduce their standards when an athlete is involved.