3 ms·

I'm saying that white people have inherited a lot of wealth at the cost of black people. Wealth statistics clearly show this. The average black family is 10x po

I'm saying that white people have inherited a lot of wealth at the cost of black people. Wealth statistics clearly show this. The average black family is 10x poorer then the average white family. The stealing was done through Jim Crow, slavery, red lining, etc. If you inherit money that your parents stole, that money is taken away from you by the police and given back to the person it was stolen from. In this case, white people's ancestors stole from black people, and therefore, white people should take responsibility for that and pay back black people since they are still benefiting from that theft at the cost of black people today who would have otherwise inherited the stolen wealth.

AdrianB1 7y ago
"White people" is a vast generalization, it includes people that came in US much later than the history you are talking about. How can you even consider punishing them for something they did not do, just because they are the same race as the people that did something bad a long time ago? This is racism in the purest form.
- Miner49er 7y ago
  Most (all?) of Europe benefited from colonialism and slavery, it wasn't just America doing it.
  - yucca_plant 7y ago
    Arab slavers took many more African slaves than the Europeans every did. How much do they have to repay?
- southphillyman 7y ago
  They immigrated to a country built on the free labor of blacks correct? Once here they were given preferential treatment in terms of unionization and local government correct? The narrative that later immigrants didn't benefit from or engage in Jim Crow is kind of ludicrous.
charliesharding 7y ago
Which wealth statistics? From this article, 90% of family wealth is lost by the third generation. http://money.com/money/3925308/rich-families-lose-wealth/ http://money.com/money/3925308/rich-families-lose-wealth/
- smashthepants 7y ago
  There are so many studies on this if you're actually interested. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ethnic_groups_in_the_United_States_by_household_income https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ethnic_groups_in_the_U... Regardless of whether family wealth is lost over time, non-black families still hold more wealth than black families by several multiples.
Vomzor 7y ago
>Irish immigrants, many of whom were very poor, were more of an underclass than the Germans. In Ireland, the English had oppressed the Irish for centuries, eradicating their language and culture and discriminating against their religion (Catholicism). Although the Irish had a larger population than the English, they were a subordinate group. This dynamic reached into the new world, where Anglo Americans saw Irish immigrants as a race apart: dirty, lacking ambition, and suitable for only the most menial jobs. In fact, Irish immigrants were subject to criticism identical to that with which the dominant group characterized African Americans. By necessity, Irish immigrants formed tight communities segregated from their Anglo neighbors. The later wave of immigrants from Southern and Eastern Europe was also subject to intense discrimination and prejudice. In particular, the dominant group—which now included second- and third-generation Germans and Irish—saw Italian immigrants as the dregs of Europe and worried about the purity of the American race (Myers 2007). Italian immigrants lived in segregated slums in Northeastern cities, and in some cases were even victims of violence and lynchings similar to what African Americans endured. They worked harder and were paid less than other workers, often doing the dangerous work that other laborers were reluctant to take on. https://courses.lumenlearning.com/alamo-sociology/chapter/reading-white-ethnic-americans/ https://courses.lumenlearning.com/alamo-sociology/chapter/re... - So I take it Irish-Americans, Italian-Americans and Americans of Eastern-European descent, most of them having arrived in states without Jim Crow laws, won't have to pay? - Will white people who's ancestors fought and died for the union side in the civil war have to pay or maybe they get a discount? - Will white people who arrived in the last 20 years have to pay? - Will poor white people have to pay? - Does this cover rich African Americans or does the money only go to those with less money than white people? - The average black family is 7x poorer than the average asian family. Does that mean Asians have to pay too?

AdrianB1 7y ago

"White people" is a vast generalization, it includes people that came in US much later than the history you are talking about. How can you even consider punishing them for something they did not do, just because they are the same race as the people that did something bad a long time ago? This is racism in the purest form.

Miner49er 7y ago
Most (all?) of Europe benefited from colonialism and slavery, it wasn't just America doing it.
- yucca_plant 7y ago
  Arab slavers took many more African slaves than the Europeans every did. How much do they have to repay?
southphillyman 7y ago
They immigrated to a country built on the free labor of blacks correct? Once here they were given preferential treatment in terms of unionization and local government correct? The narrative that later immigrants didn't benefit from or engage in Jim Crow is kind of ludicrous.

charliesharding 7y ago

Which wealth statistics? From this article, 90% of family wealth is lost by the third generation. http://money.com/money/3925308/rich-families-lose-wealth/ http://money.com/money/3925308/rich-families-lose-wealth/

smashthepants 7y ago
There are so many studies on this if you're actually interested. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ethnic_groups_in_the_United_States_by_household_income https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ethnic_groups_in_the_U... Regardless of whether family wealth is lost over time, non-black families still hold more wealth than black families by several multiples.

Vomzor 7y ago

>Irish immigrants, many of whom were very poor, were more of an underclass than the Germans. In Ireland, the English had oppressed the Irish for centuries, eradicating their language and culture and discriminating against their religion (Catholicism). Although the Irish had a larger population than the English, they were a subordinate group. This dynamic reached into the new world, where Anglo Americans saw Irish immigrants as a race apart: dirty, lacking ambition, and suitable for only the most menial jobs. In fact, Irish immigrants were subject to criticism identical to that with which the dominant group characterized African Americans. By necessity, Irish immigrants formed tight communities segregated from their Anglo neighbors. The later wave of immigrants from Southern and Eastern Europe was also subject to intense discrimination and prejudice. In particular, the dominant group—which now included second- and third-generation Germans and Irish—saw Italian immigrants as the dregs of Europe and worried about the purity of the American race (Myers 2007). Italian immigrants lived in segregated slums in Northeastern cities, and in some cases were even victims of violence and lynchings similar to what African Americans endured. They worked harder and were paid less than other workers, often doing the dangerous work that other laborers were reluctant to take on. https://courses.lumenlearning.com/alamo-sociology/chapter/reading-white-ethnic-americans/ https://courses.lumenlearning.com/alamo-sociology/chapter/re... - So I take it Irish-Americans, Italian-Americans and Americans of Eastern-European descent, most of them having arrived in states without Jim Crow laws, won't have to pay? - Will white people who's ancestors fought and died for the union side in the civil war have to pay or maybe they get a discount? - Will white people who arrived in the last 20 years have to pay? - Will poor white people have to pay? - Does this cover rich African Americans or does the money only go to those with less money than white people? - The average black family is 7x poorer than the average asian family. Does that mean Asians have to pay too?